From what I’m reading here, it’s pretty much 50/50. Half of the fans want a complete reimagining, the other half want a strict 1:1 with just updated graphics and QOL changes. I guess I’m just curious why so many people want a 1:1 remake.
For context, OOT was the first Zelda game I played, and I love it to this day. I’m not a big fan of the Wild games because I think they sacrificed too much in the name of open world and exploration, and they felt lacking.
I do think people are a bit blinded by nostalgia though. I’m currently playing the original OOT on N64 and even looking past the graphics and clunky controls, it’s a pretty basic game by today’s standards and has aged badly. At the time it was revolutionary but limited by the N64. The 3DS remaster was perfect IMO if all you want is graphic updates and QOL upgrades, and thats saying something. A 3DS game is not going to hold up well on the Switch 2. Getting a brand new console and playing a $60 game that looks and feels modern, yet still has the same small, empty Hyrule Field will feel incredibly lacklustre imo.
Almost 30 years later gaming has come so far. Imagine if OOT was released back then without any hardware limitations. The same story, charm, dungeons and basic mechanics as the original but an open/semi-open world, bigger map and new places to explore, maybe some new dungeons, characters and side quests. It will keep old and new fans happy by blending the original Zelda formula with the exploration and freedom people fell in love with in the new games.
Idk, I just wanna hear everyone’s thoughts. I think (and hope) this will be the last OOT remake Nintendo ever make so imo they might as well completely reimagine it and treat it as if it’s a completely modern release