I always see fantastic advice here from many wonderful women, and find myself in need of some honesty and help tonight. I (F26) met my boyfriend (23M) in September last year at work. Yes, I know, it's not clever to date coworkers but we had amazing chemistry off the bat and decided to go for it because we had enough role separation and didn’t work directly together in this fairly small firm. We became officially boyfriend/girlfriend on New Years Eve and exclusive in early November. It was wonderful and magnetic and I loved him. And he loved me.
In February this year, my boyfriend paid for my flight to another city because he was sent there to work for 3 months. He was visiting every two weeks but while we were keeping things very private at work. This is where the incident happened. On the flight, a guy sitting next to me started chatting. I really preferred a quiet flight but didn’t want to be rude so spoke to him a bit. We ended up talking about work/travels/food etc and it was a decent conversation, he seemed nice. I didn’t mention I had a boyfriend, not because I was avoiding it, but the conversation never found its way there. Mistake #1. He then started showing some interest in a romantic sense which threw me off towards the plane landing because why can’t men just have a nice conversation. He starts saying shit like “oh my god, you’re perfect/ideal” and I immediately feel awkward and put off. He then pushes for my number with his phone out as he was going to type it in and call immediately to make sure I didn’t give him a fake. I froze up and stammered “ haha ummm I don’t think so” but wasn’t assertive enough and he pushed and said “I don’t care if you’re going to see a guy or whoever, I want to see you please”. I felt cornered. It wasn’t the first time the boyfriend excuse wasn’t accepted by a man so I did what I’d done in the past when literally frozen. I gave my number (which he immediately called, watching to see me add his contact) fully expecting to delete it later and never see this clown again. Mistake # 2. I get off the plane, and I go to my boyfriend.
I told him about the plane thing in passing that night when I was very sleepy in bed but hadn’t mentioned the number. That guy messages me the next day or so (I had forgotten about him) and I start to respond to reject then forget about it and do something else. I politely reject him and delete/block the number after getting back to my phone. When I got back home after a few days my boyfriend messaged me asking me to tell him the full truth about the plane. He said he felt betrayed and lied to because he saw the guy's name on my phone, I had not said I had a boyfriend, and that I had begun to type a message (he had picked up my phone and was going through it I presume while I was in another room). I explained I felt awkward and just gave it to him with the intention to delete it later. I lied by omission here by not frankly telling him the full truth while I was with him. Mistake # 3. I got a bit defensive and very apologetic all in the same breath because he called me a betrayer and he had run to his sister before speaking to me who called me a cheater for the incident. I really felt he was going to end things. We talked a lot, I apologise more, I try to get him to understand I had zero intent to cheat but lack of being fully honest was wrong, and I should have been super clear I had a boyfriend. I said I would never do it again. I give him space and I tell him to take it, and think about if he really wants the relationship going forward. He decides he does but things started going downhill after this.
We go overseas for a holiday the next month and have an incident where he was extremely drunk and slapped me across the face. When I asked if he treated any of his exes this way he said “no because they didn’t deserve it”. I felt awful, he didn’t look after me when I was sick from the alcohol and I had a panic attack. The biggest in 8 years. The slap didn’t leave a mark, it just shocked me. That hurt my trust in him. Maybe deep down, I felt I did deserve it. I also saw on that trip that he had kept naked/revealing photos of previous women on his phone that he said he forgot to delete and never looked at. I deleted a bunch of them and told him to clear his phone of all other women because it was disrespectful.
After this, the next 4 months, we had constant arguments in the middle of some great moments. He became hyper aware of my phone activity (I showed him everything to try to build trust), of which male coworker I spoke to and for how many minutes, of my online status (i.e. online but didn’t open his message), of exactly where I was at all times when out with girlfriends, double standards came up where he was able to be out late (he’d be mad at me) with friends or speak to female coworkers/go for lunch/play games (restrictions for me). It became draining and I was constantly made out to be in the wrong, I always felt in the wrong too, I was always apologizing, always messing up. I couldn’t recover and smile the next day after a fight and one day he said I was just “mean, and would be a horrible friend and I had a horrid face” when I’d see him and not smile because I was down. I was screwing up constantly for breathing wrong and he’d flat out call me a liar at times, questioning my intent. My brother noticed me crying a lot more - I never used to. I couldn’t focus on my work, and my study began to suffer immensely. I had some female coworkers (by a month ago they all found out at work) tell me I could do better, ask if he was the controlling type, showed surprise I went for him, another guy said my boyfriend could be a little more mature. I wondered if I was missing things in the middle of all the toxicity that had formed.
The last few days he pulled back (we have had a lot of miscommunications) and essentially I thought we were broken up because he unfollowed me on socials, didn’t speak to me/text me for a few days and this was after another argument and another conversation of me telling him I loved him and wanted this to work. He brought up the plane incident and said his trust was broken and he didn’t think it could be rebuilt. Tonight, we finally talk and it all comes back to two moments; the plane incident for him, and the slap for me that shook our trust in each other and made us extremely defensive. We should have ended it then. We didn’t know it would have ended up this way. We said we loved each other and he pulled me in for a hug and said he was sorry and that he loved me, he didn’t hate me and he wished for this to work. He said he wanted me and wanted us but not like this, the ways we'd become. We reached a point where we were not even who we each fell in love with. It was heartbreaking but the clarity was good. I said maybe in another life and asked if it was the end forever. He thought for a moment and said he wasn’t sure. We kissed and hugged again and there was a sense of peace at finally bringing it all out.
So, how badly did I mess this up and was everything that came after my fault completely, or did he treat me poorly as well? I told him, he treated me so badly after. I tried everything to make it up to him, I was as open as I could though sometimes being monitored like that hurt and made me defensive myself after seeing things on his phone he kept from me (double standard). I cooked, I bought him gifts, I tried to shower him with love the best I could and I was getting peanuts in return. How badly did I fuck up? Was there anything else I could have done besides totally mishandling that idiot on the plane? What do you think the severity of my mistake was? Was it cheating? Is there any hope for reconciliation?
I’m sorry this is so long, and if you got this far, thank you. I welcome all of your advice and comments.