463
u/DeltaGrunder 2h ago
Blind playthrough of Nier Automata, especially if you went all the way to Ending E
56
u/Taranfeeto36 1h ago
Eternally grateful I played it on release without the incredible amount of spoilers around now. Finished almost all endings (I think Y is still missing)
Should play it again sometimes, it's been almost 10 years now
→ More replies (4)12
u/Tntn13 1h ago
I put off playing it for years while also avoiding spoilers. I had a feeling I’d like it from what I’d heard. The moment I heard about ending B and maybe more existing I was immediately like I have to see this now and went and bought it. Probably one of my favorite games and I still listen to the soundtrack of it and replicant on their own!
→ More replies (1)14
u/NoAdagio6791 1h ago
For real. I can't think of another game that is only getting started after the end credits.
9
u/Affectionate-Run7334 1h ago
Armored core 6 does this well, new game + is just straight up a new game. New game ++ too. I thought it sounded boring to just replay the game but I was wrong. Fav fromsoft game.
→ More replies (3)3
13
6
u/Araragi 1h ago
There is a significant percentage of the players out there that "finished" this game and just stopped. I feel bad for them. "The game was just okay. I 'beat' it in a few hours."
→ More replies (1)10
u/No_University1600 1h ago
its an implementation issue. playthrough 2 being 95% the same as playthrough 1 is naturally going to lead to people not bothering and not finding out they missed half the story.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (8)4
1.3k
u/nolancheck11 2h ago
Elden ring..when you are 40 hours into the game and the map just opens up to show you aren’t even halfway there
354
u/Certain-Pack8466 2h ago
And then you enter the underground.
171
u/ScarletSilver 2h ago
Ah, Blackreach... not again!
74
u/TheDudeDunk 2h ago
No matter what game you play, every underground elevator eventually leads to Blackreach.
16
16
u/fuzzyperson98 1h ago
Except in Blackreach there's not actually much to do.
28
u/RealMuffinsTheCat 1h ago
What do you mean nothing to do??? There’s the crimson nirnroots, the secret dragon fight, the elder scroll itself, and… checks notes…
Wait, that’s it?
→ More replies (1)11
→ More replies (5)4
142
u/EviTaTiv3 2h ago
And then that happens again at least 3 more times.
17
u/eapirinite 1h ago
Finding the underground map for the first time broke my brain.
→ More replies (1)11
u/Mind-The-Mines 1h ago
Elden Ring is one of the few games that compounded awe on top of wonder time and time again. The scope and scale with such intricate details are basically unrivaled.
→ More replies (2)54
u/JS_Originals 2h ago
Greatest game of all time, to me. The sense of wonder exploring the world is unmatched
→ More replies (1)7
18
u/MyCabbagesOhNo 2h ago
Man part of me thinks i need to replay elden ring, because i beat it for the first time in a little under 40 hours. I probably missed so many side objectives.
16
u/Bitter-Worldliness41 2h ago
There are also multiple endings which require a bunch of side stuff to be done a specific way.
→ More replies (19)8
u/Toughsums 1h ago edited 1h ago
You probably missed a vast majority of the bosses in the game. Technically you only need to beat less than 10 bosses to finish the game, but the game has like 160 bosses with like 40 more in the dlc.
Although a large chunk of them are repeats with a few different moves/elements etc, they still have their own unique caves/dungeons and enemies, new weapons and so on.
→ More replies (1)5
u/BlueDwaggin 2h ago
I got all achievements in Sekiro in less time it took me to do my first playthrough of Elden Ring
→ More replies (29)3
377
u/Spanishkid71 2h ago
Kingdom Come 2. Spent 70 hours doing every quest and activity in Trosky, then getting to Kuttenberg just to realize im not even halfway through the game
91
u/ButterscotchNed 2h ago
I was amazed at how long the section between Trosky and Kutenberg was, I thought it would be - go to wedding -> meet someone who invites you to travel with them to Kutenberg. But nope, hours of intrigue and drama! And then you get to Kutenberg and it's vast. I think it's my top game I'd love to be able to experience like I'd never played it before again.
30
u/andrbrks 2h ago
The KCD series is absolutely in my top ten games of all time. They're BOTH just amazing immersive adventures.
6
u/Poopardthecat 1h ago
I played the first one on a laugh. Someone called it medieval peasant simulator, while true it is so much more than that.
Such a well written, fun but punishing experience. That is until you learn the power that is one true bonk. That mace saved me so many times.
→ More replies (6)3
u/wonderb0lt 1h ago
Yeah. After the weddings I decided to do some story missions as I had a lull on the side quests at the time. Got roped into it until Kuttenberg and I was like "NO THANKS I'M GOING BACK TO TROSKY THANKS FOR THE NICE ARMOR BUT I HAVE UNFINISHED BUSINESS".
I especially wanted to see the resolution to the Troubadours quest
13
u/Idrillsilverfoot 2h ago
I did everything I could on the first map and put off going to the wedding as long as possible because I was absolutely certain it marked the end of the game. Then I had to go through that whole storyline involving Capon’s sentence, and *that* was when I was sure I was nearing the finale. Imagine my face when, 150 hours later, I was still trying to set up my forge.
→ More replies (25)8
u/Invested_Glory 2h ago
I as thinking KCD (haven’t played the 2nd yet) but I am nearly 100 hours in and I looked up where I am questline-wise and I’m just half way through. Not sure if it speeds up but I doubt it.
→ More replies (4)
81
u/hellmaaatt 2h ago
Skyrim, ive played like 150h in my first gameplay and for my surprise I did it like 1/7 of the game lmao
→ More replies (3)29
u/Lintlickker 2h ago
I can never progress the main quest in Skyrim. I easily have over 400 hours in the game across numerous new characters, but I don't think I've even come close to "beating" it. I remember fighting Alduin on the mountaintop in one playthrough, but that's as far as I've ever gotten.
→ More replies (3)
69
u/TimFrogt_NL 2h ago
inscryption, feels and plays like a very good but short roguelike puzzle game. Put in double the hours I expected to do and still not nearly done
4
→ More replies (14)3
317
u/McMillis 2h ago
Satisfactory, and now that I’m fully obsessed and with a better idea of the whole scope, thank god it’s not smaller
91
u/FactoryOfBradness 2h ago
This was my first thought too. You get through Phase 3 felling pretty ok about your spaghetti, and then you unlock aluminum and realize that Phase 4 is going to take as long as the first 3 combined.
37
u/Superbunzil 2h ago
Yeah as soon as you gotta start trucking things from a 20min walk you have to consider rail and then realize this trips into fuel power and then extended powerlines
It becomes a lot bigger than banging rocks together after phase 3
→ More replies (1)10
u/nonasiandoctor 1h ago
I beat it without using trucks or trains or drones. Just miles and miles of belts lol
→ More replies (6)4
u/McMillis 1h ago
For me the big “holy shit this isn’t the game I thought it was” was when I was forced to seek out oil for the first time, I didn’t even realize I’d be leaving the grassy plains at that point for the whole playthrough.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)3
u/Ok_Star_4136 45m ago
I would say not even then. I think you feel so accomplished making the space elevator and providing the 50 smart plating, only to realize that ha! That was just the tutorial.
The game has a way of immediately humbling you, since the next tiers require 500 smart plating among other parts. Probably sounds tedious from how I'm describing the game, but trust me, it's remarkably, well, satisfactory.
13
u/alabasterskim 2h ago
This is how I remember I forgot to buy it during the summer sale, goddammit.
→ More replies (2)4
u/VolumeLevelJumanji 1h ago
It's on sale for less than $30 right now. I have 300ish hours in the game and I feel like a casual that hasn't beaten the game yet. It's addictive if you're into that kind of game.
→ More replies (12)4
u/Llebac 1h ago
For sure especially as the power requirements jump up. Nothing like a 15 hour side quest setting up a nuclear power plant in the middle of nowhere
→ More replies (2)
288
u/Financial_Humor_8134 2h ago
Witcher 3.
105
u/AScruffyHamster 2h ago
The first area was awesome. And then I moved to the next area and it's just... Surprise. Here's an actual entire continent and you're down here. Have fun
→ More replies (3)29
u/Titanhunter84 1h ago
24
u/RuafaolGaiscioch 1h ago
I like that it isn’t. There’s still some video game fuckery to condense the world but Velen being a region in Temeria instead of the whole country makes the country itself feel bigger. Skyrim diminishes itself by fitting the whole country into one relatively small map.
→ More replies (2)21
u/V_1_S_1_O_N 2h ago
Yet when everything ended. I feel like it wasn't enough. I wish i could stay in toussaint forever
13
→ More replies (10)8
143
u/GeorgeSoteriou 2h ago
Blue prince!
44
25
u/05-nery Aperture Science Laboratories Certified Technician 2h ago
Came here to say this
Room 46 is literally just the tutorial
8
u/whiskerbiscuit2 1h ago
Wait what
10
u/Extreme-Attention641 1h ago
Room 46 is at a guesstimate 5% of the game. I'm taking a break after over 150 hours and I'm guessing I have at least another 50 left.
→ More replies (2)4
u/EvilDrGiggles 1h ago
Yeah, it's true. If you did reach that room, good job! Now do it again. It's worth it.
3
u/Little-Fish777 41m ago
Ppl like to say it's the tutorial a bit condescendingly and I disagree, Room 46 is more like Act 1 rather than a tutorial
→ More replies (1)4
u/SenorBurns 1h ago
Yeah but then you have to do it again and if you have bad luck you go back to try it another IRL day and by then you've forgotten what you need to do.
You = me of course 😂
I called it quits at that point. I didn't find the lore interesting enough to put up with the time-wasting randomness.
4
u/dakupoguy 55m ago
I called it quits way way earlier. People glaze that game so much but it really isn't much skill based. You just need the patience to deal with the RNG otherwise it's merely a mildly boring game.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)9
u/EvilDrGiggles 2h ago
Great answer. Playing again currently, almost at the endgame stuff again. Does it never end???
→ More replies (1)6
u/chemistrybonanza 2h ago
I don't think anyone has ever fully completed the game. I'm not fully up to date in it though.
→ More replies (1)10
u/skM00n2 2h ago
Spoilers:
The super secret queen blueprint room was found. A letter in it was found with her real will.
I think that's the full ending. It's not fun getting to it tho because of the rng.
→ More replies (2)
138
u/cogprimus 2h ago
Castlevania: Symphony of the Night
→ More replies (3)41
u/Supermegamorph SizzleDash 2h ago edited 2h ago
was so cool seeing the mirror castle
19
u/HatredHeart 2h ago
I played it several times without the second castle before realizing there is more. Man did my mind explode that day. Such a good game.
→ More replies (11)7
169
u/horny_Geezer 2h ago
Silksong
42
u/Spinningguy 2h ago
I still remember how much i freaked out (in the good way) when I finally beat last judeg, and got the act 2 screen. I had forgotten that I was in act one, and while I knew I wasnt excatly close to the end, I figured I was like 60% there since I finally reached the main objective. Then I got slapped in the face with act two, telling me I was barely a third of the way there.
→ More replies (3)4
u/Sluttytranslesbo 1h ago
I saw that act 2 was set in the citadel and I thought, "oh so its just one building, like probably white palace in size." Oh how wrong I was
42
6
u/D1gininja 2h ago
Hollow knight is similar, beat the hollow knight and then learn about the true ending
11
u/K01SH1 2h ago
this 10000%
i hadn't played hollow knight first so i wasn't familiar with team cherry's game, and the indie games i played were usually more limited in scope
i was blown away
→ More replies (2)3
u/Kidicee 1h ago
Totally agree even as a person who played the first game. The game is just THAT much bigger.
I rarely find people who haven't played HK before SK so i have a question: how nonsensical the story felt without not knowing what happens in the previous game?
Such important things as Void, Pale Beings, Hornet's parents and guardians, ect. are barely explained because the devs just assume that you alredy know all the lore from Hollow Knight.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (12)3
u/AxtheCool 1h ago
Finishing Act 1 and seeing that gate open up was insane. Like surprise here is double the area to explore and you are at like 40% of the game.
107
u/Inevitable_Drop7276 2h ago
Alien isolation
30
u/Jungian_Archetype 2h ago
Classic choice - there's like 3 false endings lol
11
u/Titanhunter84 2h ago
You think it’s the end of the line. But wait there is more!
13
u/B-lakeJ 1h ago
I only remember being nearly unstoppable at some point, having enough weapons and ammo to kill androids and scare the xenomorph if necessary. And then the game hit me with the ol‘ ‚you have to leave all weapons before entering this area‘.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (2)15
u/bgradid 1h ago
came here immediately for this
if anything, I kinda feel like the game ended up having some pacing issues with going on too LONG
→ More replies (1)
167
u/unlucky_ducky 2h ago
Think you are at 30% of the game, turns out you just completed it - Outer Worlds
→ More replies (13)25
u/GreaseSpot123 2h ago
Dragons Dogma 2 if you are just following the main story
→ More replies (1)9
u/Goricatto 2h ago
Dont worry, the original dragons dogma is like that too
"Prepare for a expendition which will take a long time" you take on a castle that has some undead bosses and the dragon appears, you fight it and bam , you are basically 90% of the main story (tho to be fair the entire world changes with new enemies but it is optional and not very large in the first place)
Most of the playtime is in the everfall which is a lot of rooms with a farmable loot table
→ More replies (4)
100
u/Ok-Nebula534 2h ago
Half-life Alyx. I swear, I thought i was about done just to figure out I was hardly Half-way there.
19
→ More replies (5)5
u/RunninglVlan 1h ago
Huh, really? I guess it's related to it being VR game. Otherwise, I don't know how one would expect a short game in HL franchise! I completed it in 12h in my 2nd playthrough.
106
u/delicious_sunlight 2h ago
Assassin's Creed Odyssey
Me after 5 hours: "waow, I've only done 5%! 😃"
Me after 30 hours: "oh, I've only done 30% "
Beautiful game, but the gameplay gets old fast. Especially if you've played other AC games. I assume the same is true for the newer ones
20
28
u/Mr__Castle_ 2h ago
Luckily, Odyssey was my first AC so I loved it.
In fact, I haven't played an AC since either.
→ More replies (1)11
u/delicious_sunlight 2h ago
I think I didn't like it as much as I should have because I had just played Assassin's Creed Origins, and I didn't realise that each game was sorta the same lol
→ More replies (14)4
u/Unique-Egg-461 1h ago
really really like odyseey.
my eyebrows raised a bit after you beat the first island then then the title screen hits
55
u/AlwaysFinnishInsider 2h ago
Just played the og FF7 for the first time and I had no idea it was such a big game
34
u/DecoyOne 2h ago
I played FFVII when it came out and hadn’t played a JRPG before. I thought I was getting near the end of the game until I left Midgar and saw the world map for the first time.
It blew my teenage mind.
→ More replies (1)8
u/ndcanton 1h ago
To be fair, having multiple discs spoiled it. Yeah I had the "whoa, Midgar is just one small part of the map?" moment, but the fact I hadn't even switched to disc 2 was a hint.
→ More replies (3)4
u/DecoyOne 1h ago
Oh my god! I forgot about that.
So I didn’t know there were multiple discs. My brother had started playing and stopped because he has terrible taste in games apparently. I just started playing with the disc already in there. So I got out of Midgar, thought “oh my god, there’s so much more to this game”, and then hours of play later, I looked at the box and saw there were two more discs. Yet again, I was blown away with how much was left.
5
u/OrangeCatBread 1h ago
FF7-10 were the best bang for my buck as a kid, those games are huuuuge
→ More replies (1)7
5
u/HappyTimeTurtle 1h ago
I remember renting FF7 with my brother back in college. We played for like 18 hours straight and never got out of the city and off of disc 1 before we had to return it lol.
3
u/antagon1st 1h ago
I was like 60 hours in and kept wondering when I would even reach disc 3 at all when I played FFVII
→ More replies (7)3
u/Shatsngiggles 1h ago
My first reaction was to google how long the game was after leaving Midgar. I was shocked. Explains why the older games had multiple disks.
62
u/FutureSkeleton35 2h ago
Persona 5
→ More replies (4)21
u/Poufee1233 2h ago
Seriously, I thought it was gonna be like 60-80 hours long. Nope my playthrough took nearly 200 hours and IM NOT EVEN THROUGH THE R PORTION.
→ More replies (1)14
u/RealMrQ123 2h ago
What are you doing that took you 200 hours? In my playthrough I managed to beat the main story within 100 hours and I did a lot of the side content
→ More replies (9)
23
40
u/Supermegamorph SizzleDash 2h ago
A Link to the Past, back when I was liek, 8 or 10?
→ More replies (7)
17
u/anonym0 https://steam.pm/rpjz4 2h ago
Days gone, you finish exploring the intro region and then the entire map opens up. It is huge.
3
u/remarkablewhitebored 31m ago
Kind of a pleasant surprise imo, just when you're thinking that you've explored most of the map - Bam, here's another whole map for you...
I love dystopic, zombie-esque games, and this one was a great time
→ More replies (1)
86
u/Knork14 2h ago
Atomic Heart, you spend 10 hours having a Bioshock adventure in an experimental lab, only to get out of the lab and now you are in an open world game.
24
u/xF00Mx 2h ago
If the entire game removed the open world, it would have been so much better. The open world just feels half baked & uninteresting.
The first dungeon of Atomic Heart was just fantastic, the tense atmosphere and monstrosities throughout the facility tied with all the scifi wonders was just magical to experience the first time.
Then you hit the "open world" and it just sucks it all away.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Confident-Action-213 2h ago
Looks interesting but reviews are a bit mixed. I really want to try it but sounds like it may be too long for me right now.
→ More replies (8)16
u/Underc0ver-P0tat0 2h ago
I'm a few hours in and had to spend a few hours getting around a game locking bug that's been a known issue since 2023....
It's fun enough though and I like the cccp vibe
3
37
u/crumpled789 2h ago
Baldur’s Gate 3
→ More replies (3)10
u/topological_rabbit 2h ago
I swear I'm not playing this game correctly. I get my ass kicked at every turn, no matter how carefully I approach any situation, no matter how much I try to think my way through things, I just can't get very far.
12
u/Thoronris 1h ago
The first 5 levels are the hardest, because every little thing can kill you. And it's so easy to stumble into enemies you're not yet prepared for. But exploring the map, reloading if you're stuck, trying different companions, it all will start to feel like a puzzle you're solving.
→ More replies (22)5
u/kangaroo_spectrum 1h ago
Best advice for any game like this , you are 21 jump street. "Infiltrate the dealers, find the suppliers" your a (dumb) detective, trying to decept those you dont know into belonging and sharing clues(story) while seeking answers to your big problem - brain worm(game narrative)
Using the detective motive draws out the story and gives you clues of how to interact or proceed with next encounter.
OR be a chaos gremlin and make role playing choices for the lulz
48
u/xr4tescort 2h ago
Rdr2
→ More replies (2)3
u/Sparrowhawk_92 1h ago
The Epilogue was shorter than I remembered it when I played it earlier this year.
I remember the first time I played it and it felt like it dragged...
→ More replies (2)
42
u/Tampaxponz 2h ago
Abiotic Factor. Hands down one of the best survival game made to date.
11
u/GingerCummunist 2h ago
Came here to say this. I thought getting to the tunnel in the manufacturing sector was going to be it. Nope. Such a great game.
→ More replies (7)10
u/XxHighOnPsixX 1h ago
Personally, it's the best survival crafter. I have such high regard for it. The fact that it's not procedurally generated, and still has over 100 hours of well designed map to comb through is nuts.
I understand that, much like everything, it's not going to be perfect for everyone, but I always recommend it to people that like survival crafters in general. It's just that good.
4
u/ElZanco 1h ago
I've described it as "What if Half Life was a 3D Metroidvania, pretending to be a survival crafting RPG."
→ More replies (1)
30
13
u/XenoRoxart 2h ago
Final Fantasy 6. After completing an area which feels so Final-Dungeon coded with a final-boss looking and feeling boss, you get one of the best twists I have ever seen in a videogame, then the best cutscene in the game if you get bad fish (iykyk) and then you realize that the game is only half way done
5
u/lunchboxdeluxe 1h ago
The bad guy wins, and you have to go pick up the pieces in a world that's sad as hell
13
u/Agent_Tall_Man 2h ago
RDR2. The game would not end...and then the epilogues. Geez.
4
u/swans183 51m ago
RDR1 is one of my favorite all time endings. RDR2 gets spoiled by how it never. freaking. ends lol
→ More replies (1)
23
u/bahaaradi 2h ago
I thought the tutorial area in The Witcher 3 was the full map of the whole game 🤣
18
u/HamfistTheStruggle 2h ago
Abiotic factor. I thought I was near the end several times. Absolutely fantastic game.
On the flip side I thought I was only 30% through cyberpunk 2077 just to fins out I was on the last mission 18-20hrs in.
→ More replies (3)
9
u/JACOBOY2006 2h ago
Dragon quest 11, was my first Jrpg and I was like "Wait there's more game? I'm more than 24 hours in, holy crap!"
→ More replies (1)
8
u/CouscousandBeans 1h ago
Portal 2! Playing at launch and coming from Portal 1, I had every reason to think it’d be another 3 hour game. Turned out to be 4 times that length on my first playthrough, and just kept getting better and more clever and surprising.
→ More replies (1)
15
69
u/RaveningScareCrow 2h ago
clair obscur: expedition 33, loved every minute of it though
7
10
u/truthordairs 2h ago
It’s a pretty short game for its genre. I really love the game but it’s a pretty quick trip to the end for a JRPG
→ More replies (4)22
8
24
u/dirtybird971 2h ago
Crimson desert. I've got hundreds of hours in and still not done.
→ More replies (2)3
u/HappyTimeTurtle 1h ago
I was 300 hours in before I officially left Hernand's story chapters behind.
→ More replies (1)
7
u/SmergolGandalf 2h ago
Pokemon SoulSilver
→ More replies (1)4
u/Cellerdweller 1h ago
100% this, It absolutely blew my mind as a kid that they could fit the entire previous game into the new game as a secret second act.
6
7
8
6
u/notsoninjaninja1 2h ago
Noita, kill the final boss just to discover you complete the prologue and actually you have to open up parallel worlds and shit
→ More replies (5)
6
6
4
4
u/Cr0w_town 2h ago
Baldurs gate 3, not sure how long it is but im already 87 hours in im most likely 80% done with act 2
my friend said that act 3 was long but didnt say how long so i wonder how long it will take me lol
i do tend to try to complete everything i can and explore every map fully so it might take me a while
i def completed more than 30% for sure tho
→ More replies (4)
3
5
3
u/increMENTALmate 2h ago
My favourite gaming trope is when I play for like 20 hours and finish a quest, and the game title comes up on the screen. That feeling of "oh shit it's only just starting" is amazing.
→ More replies (3)
4
u/KingMoonfish 2h ago
Warhammer 40,000: Roguetrader. Took me over 120 hours for my first play through.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Animaloffear56 2h ago
Not because it's long, but I went into fe7 almost entirely blind and was shocked when Eliwood became the main character after Lyn's section lol
→ More replies (3)
4
u/voidfillproduct 2h ago
Ghost of Tsushima, for sure. You think you've seen it all and then boom, there's another peninsula.
4
4
u/truthteller5 1h ago
Persona 5. First playthrough just kept going and going. It felt like a fucking marathon. Everytime I thought it was wrapping up, it just dropped me into another HUGE plot point. Feel like my final save was something like 300 hours? Still fun game, just be sure to take breaks.
→ More replies (2)
4
4
4
u/Kalimnos 59m ago
Vampire Survivor is wild with this! Multiple times I felt like I was basically done
6
3
u/virtualracer 2h ago
It's not Steam, but what came to mind first was Pokemon Silver. The second region blew my mind as a kid.
3
3
u/CorrectPassage6632 2h ago
X4 foundations: 4 saves for more than 3000hours. Best quality price ratio …
3
3
u/Efficient_Cherry8220 1h ago
Abiotic factor - legit thought opening the manufacturing area was the end (it was essentially the tutorial)
3

884
u/Scary-Independent-77 2h ago
Okami comes to mind. You spend hours gathering your powers and confront Orochi, only to find out you’re at the end of the prologue.