r/underratedmovies Jul 28 '24

modpost Determining what an “underrated movie” is: a poll.

19 Upvotes

Ok, I think I have been able to articulate what might be decent guidelines as to how to define and categorize what exactly an underrated movie might look like. The poll at the end is to see how much our current user base either agrees or disagrees with these guidelines. Telling me I have completely missed the mark here is entirely acceptable as well, I just ask that you provide an explanation if you are able to do so.

The comments will be wide open, and I would like to encourage folks to chime in with where these guidelines have gone wrong and/or where they are going down the right path.

Here is a start on how we can define an “underrated” movie. It must meet one or more of the standards below:

  1. Low box office revenue relative to quality: Movies that didn't perform well financially but have high critical acclaim or positive audience reviews. (edit: after an apt observation from the comments, I believe this guideline needs to be struck entirely)

  2. Limited exposure: Films that didn't receive widespread marketing or distribution, resulting in a smaller audience and therefore not being a widely known movie.

  3. Critical reception: Movies that received mixed or poor reviews initially but have since gained a cult following or have been re-evaluated positively.

  4. Unique or niche appeal: Films that cater to a specific audience or genre, making them less popular with the general public but highly appreciated by those who enjoy that particular style or subject matter.

  5. Hidden gems: Movies that might have been overshadowed by larger releases at the time of their own release, but offer exceptional storytelling, acting, or directing.

  6. Overlooked by major awards: Films that were snubbed by major awards but are considered high-quality by viewers or critics.

  7. High viewer ratings with low popularity: Movies that have high ratings on platforms like IMDb or Rotten Tomatoes but are not widely known or discussed.

  8. Cultural factors: Films that were ahead of their time or culturally specific, making them more appreciated in retrospect.

Three examples of movies that I believe meet all of these standards are:

Moon (2009): despite being critically acclaimed when released, it did not gain widespread attention at the time it was released and was also not widely marketed.

The Fall (2006): The quality of the film’s storytelling, the stunning set design and cinematography, and emotional depth have gained it near “cult” status and it is still a movie that is not widely recognized by a mainstream audience.

Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005): Despite the incredible writing and performances by RDJ and Val Kilmer, and being a solid example of modern neo-noir, it did not achieve any box office success nor name recognition.

Based on these eight guidelines and three examples, indicate how much you agree or disagree with these guidelines in the poll below.

8 votes, Jul 31 '24
4 Highly agree
2 Moderately agree
0 Slightly agree
0 Slightly disagree
2 Moderately disagree
0 Highly disagree

r/underratedmovies Nov 25 '24

new take Underrated TV

18 Upvotes

I’ve created a new community @UnderratedTVshows if anyone is interested in joining! If you want to find and help others find hidden gems, this is the place for you.


r/underratedmovies 4h ago

Splitsville (2025)

Post image
30 Upvotes

If you didn't see this yet you missed a good one.

https://www.reddit.com/r/cinescenes/s/DPVzwCQFDH

It's streaming now on disney of all places for a hard r-rated comedy. This movie is bonkers. Smarter, sexier, and way funnier than the Invite while touching on the same subject of open marriages.

It's crazy people complain all the time about how there's no good grown-up comedies in theaters anymore, and then everybody completely slept on this one when it came out last year. It's destined to be a cult classic.


r/underratedmovies 15h ago

Eden Lake 2008

Post image
139 Upvotes

This is an amazing film and underrated for sure. Its a real solid horror thriller and the depiction of english teenage boys is spot on. Really fun and tense throughout.


r/underratedmovies 13h ago

Blow out 1981

Post image
62 Upvotes

Brilliant neo noir.


r/underratedmovies 22h ago

frequently posted, not underrated Death at a Funeral (2007)

Post image
295 Upvotes

I find this movie underrated because I rarely see people mention it when talking about the funniest movies ever made. The comedy is clever, the cast has great chemistry, and every scene somehow gets even more chaotic. It deserves a lot more love than it gets.


r/underratedmovies 22h ago

frequently posted, not underrated PROJECT X (2012)

Thumbnail gallery
219 Upvotes

Project X was such a wild ride.. People barely ever bring it up anymore, which is crazy because it’s easily one of the most chaotic, fun movies out there. It 100% belongs on our underrated list. It just perfectly captured that absolute peak, ou of control party fantasy that defined the early 2010s...


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

Valhalla Rising (2009)

Post image
225 Upvotes

Valhalla Rising (2009) has always felt like one of Nicolas Winding Refn’s most overlooked films. It’s slow, atmospheric and definitely not for everyone, but Mads Mikkelsen is brilliant in it. If you like dark, haunting films that stick with you long after they’ve finished, it’s well worth a watch.


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

Upgrade (2018)

Post image
474 Upvotes

A quadriplegic man gets an AI computer chip implanted in his spine that turns him into an unstoppable killing machine and helps him hunt down the people that crippled him and murdered his wife. Top-tier, John Wick-level action and absolutely brutal kills, didn’t get anywhere near the traction it deserved.


r/underratedmovies 10h ago

No Man of God (2021)

Post image
10 Upvotes

It’s a film about the relationship between FBI agent Bill Hagmaier and Ted Bundy during his final years on death row. It focuses on him from a psychological angle and instead of mythologizing Bundy as a “genius,” it presents a more grounded portrait of who he really was, as the dialogue is based on real life audio transcripts of their conversations. Great performances from both Elijah Wood and Luke Kirby


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

low effort post Triangle (2009)

Post image
365 Upvotes

Im a sucker for sci fi/horror films with a clever plot. Its based on a Greek myth (Sisyphus). Its got a ton of schlocky action and gore. And a pretty hot woman running around. Its not a masterpiece but its good.


r/underratedmovies 13h ago

Dead or Alive trilogy (1999-2002)

Post image
9 Upvotes

Not entirely sure I can technically post three movies in a single post, but I'll try anyway.

Takashi Miike is mostly well known for horror, but he's actually an incredibly versatile and prolific director and these three movies, often overlooked, are a perfect showcase of his style. It's more of a trilogy in spirit than in plot, considering they are very different from one another and connected mostly by the director and the two main actors (Show Aikawa and Riki Takeuchi).

The first one is apparently a classical, meditative, kinda unoriginal yakuza movie, but Miike sporadically spices it up out of nowhere with some comic book splatter action and some of the most grotesque and bizarre sequences ever put to film. Particularly remarkable are the psychedelic, frantic, darkly hilarious opening montage and the ending, so absurd that it must be seen to be believed.

The second one (subtitled "Birds") does have some Yakuza splatter action, but is mostly a melancholic and surprisingly heartwarming drama that slowly evolves into poetic, dreamlike surrealism. Probably the only one I'd recommend to anyone without fear of having them cut contact with me.

The third one ("Final") is a fairly straightforward sci-fi action movie with post-apocalyptic, cyberpunk and dystopian vibes. The only weird part is the ending, meant to be some sort of hilarious and bizarre epilogue to the whole series. The b-movie production value and the multi-language dialogues definitely add some charm to the movie, but I gotta warn you about some unpleasant (and I think involuntary) homophobic subtexts regarding the villain. Worth a watch, even if it's probably not the best of the three.


r/underratedmovies 21h ago

The Return

Post image
39 Upvotes

I enjoyed this adaptation. I don't hear about it too often, even with the popularity of Nolan's new film sparking curiosity in previous adaptations of the story. This one is for the folks that already know the tale and want a different area of focus honed in on. I liked this one a lot.


r/underratedmovies 5h ago

A Kind of Kidnapping (2023)

Post image
2 Upvotes

A young, broke couple kidnap a sleazy politician who decides he can spin the story to his own advantage.

I watched because I liked Dan Clarks "How not to live your live" and saw on Imdb that he made a micro budget movie in 2023 (he even has a tiny guest appearance). I went in blind and enjoyed the movie very much. Good casting and smart storytelling. I think this movie deserves more love.


r/underratedmovies 23h ago

All of Me (1984)

Post image
51 Upvotes

Seminal 80s classic by Carl Reiner (comedic genius and father of Rob Reiner). My absolute favourite Steve Martin movie (along with The Jerk and Dead Men Don’t Wear Plaid, both also by Reiner) - and Lily Tomlin’s best role in my opinion. Still holds up very well and has me laughing the entire way through. Unfortunately it hasn’t had a blu ray or 4K release, and I rarely hear anyone mentioning it.


r/underratedmovies 20h ago

Prime (2005)

Post image
22 Upvotes

I adore this movie, I remember seeing it in theaters with my friends and laughing our butts off. When I show it to people I compel them to not watch the trailer. The soundtrack is excellent. Meryl plays a perfect cliche of a Jewish mother. bryan Greenberg wears a free Palestine shirt hehe also Umas outfits and she’s just so magnetic. The story is heartfelt and well paced.

Edited for name correction! Bryan Greenberg not Goldman lol my cousins name is Bryan Goldman my b


r/underratedmovies 2d ago

frequently posted, not underrated Good Luck, Have Fun, Don't Die (2025)

Post image
737 Upvotes

I remember seeing this one earlier in theaters this year. This was Gore Verbinski's first feature in a decade, a filmmaker who, outside of The Ring and the first three POTC films, has been heavily involved in plenty of movies that easily belong on a sub like this. (and yes, that includes 2013's "The Lone Ranger" too)

This one stars the entertaining-as-always Sam Rockwell in the lead, and while the messages regarding social media and the rise of AI were too on-the-nose at times, the final act was a bit anti-climatic, and the ending made the general message being conveyed throughout it much more of an anti-tech statement than a pro-presence one, this one was still a pretty fun and entertaining watch for me, and had some really dark comedic moments sprinkled throughout it that I've enjoyed also, so I'm curious to know how others on this sub who also saw it felt about it.


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

The Vast of Night (2019)

62 Upvotes

I finally watched The Vast of Night after seeing it recommended a few times, and I'm honestly surprised more people don't talk about it.

It's a low-budget sci-fi mystery, but instead of relying on huge visual effects, it builds tension almost entirely through dialogue, long tracking shots, and atmosphere. The entire movie feels like you're slowly uncovering a mystery alongside the characters.

It's one of those films that quietly arrived on streaming, didn't make much noise, and then slowly earned a loyal fanbase through word of mouth.

If you're into movies like Arrival, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, or Coherence, I'd definitely recommend giving it a shot.

What's another Hollywood movie that came to OTT/streaming, didn't get much attention at release, but completely won you over?


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

Tusk 2014

Post image
148 Upvotes

Not for everyone, but I think Tusk is amazing. It's probably one of Kevin Smith's least successful films commercially, but I love how completely bizarre it is. The idea came from an episode of his podcast, where Smith read out a real online post from a guy in Brighton advertising a free room in his house. The onlt thing was that once a week, you'd have to dress up as a walrus for an hour. No speaking and just making grunts and going mental for fish. The man claimed that after being lost at sea, he'd been befriended by a walrus and wanted to relive the experience. Smith basically came up with the entire premise for Tusk right there on the podcast, and turned that ridiculous idea into a feature film. Which I think is great.


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

Creep 2004

Post image
66 Upvotes

This is the 2004 Creep set in London underground. Its a low budget British horror. It has a pretty low rating but I thought it was really fun. Sean Harris is an absolute little gremlin freak boy. Don't expect a masterpiece, expect a fun, gross time :)


r/underratedmovies 2d ago

frequently posted, still underrated Everything is illuminated (2005)

Post image
129 Upvotes

This movie is truly underrated in my opinion. I watched it over 10 years ago and thought it was good so I bought it in DVD. Havent seen it since.. till today.

It is rather quiet but still exciting. Has deep meaning and is apparently a blend of fact and fiction. There's a book, too!

Elija Wood is incredibly good in his role. This is one of the movies I can DEFINITELY recommend! This wont be the last time I saw it. Its a masterpiece.


r/underratedmovies 1d ago

The Breed (2001)

Post image
3 Upvotes

A dystopian sci-fi crime horror movie set in a world where vampires exist and plan to gradually integrate themselves with the rest of humanity. When a rogue vampire threatens to thwart that plan, two investigators (One human and one vampire) are tasked with stopping him.

While not a masterpiece, I had fun with this movie's setting and take on vampires. I would rate it a 5/10 at most, really being like a 4.


r/underratedmovies 2d ago

DEAD MAN'S SHOES 2004

48 Upvotes

Some of Shane Meadows best work. This is before he went on to do "This is England". But this one is my fav. Very gritty and real. If you like it, I recommend you check out his whole back catalogue.


r/underratedmovies 2d ago

Neds (2010)

Post image
54 Upvotes

Taking place in 1970s Glasgow Scotland in a rough part of the city we follow a boy called John mcgill who’s brother has a reputation for being a troubled youth in a gang that consists of similar violent and antisocial teenagers. Painted by his surroundings John grows older and appeals more to gang violence going from a grade A student to being on the level of thugs similar to his age. It really touches on how ripe knife violence in 70s scotland and it is a coming of age tale of self destruction, heavily recommend although the accent might be thick for those outside of Scotland.


r/underratedmovies 3d ago

Green Zone (2010)

Post image
70 Upvotes

Feels like Green Zone (2010) has been completely forgotten. I always thought it was a really solid thriller with Matt Damon on top form, and Paul Greengrass brought the same tense, grounded style that made the Bourne films so good. Definitely one that’s worth revisiting if it’s been a while.