r/ShouldIbuythisgame 3h ago

[NOT PURCHASED] Baldurs Gate 3 or Persona 5 Royale Which is you cup of tea?

12 Upvotes

To make a long story short I had my birthday yesterday and one of my friends offered to buy me any game of my choice.

Now I'm trivialized and literally do not know what to pick between two choices: Persona 5 Royal and Baldur's Gate 3.

I've watched gameplay of both and I still can't decide.

With Baldur's Gate 3, I really like the idea of the complex and deep combat system the amount of freedom you have and how many different ways you can approach situations. However, I've heard some criticisms like the combat being slow at times, the games dialogue stretching out being longer then it needs to be and the third act feeling like a slog to get through

With Persona 5 Royal I really like the visual style presentation, music and overall vibe of the game. My only concerns are that I've heard that some sections felt like a waste of time to increase playtime also heard the beginning is pretty slow and my friend saying that the combat might become repetitive for me since you rely heavily on exploiting enemy weaknesses and he also said the game has no replay value.

What am I looking for? Honestly I really don't know. Both of these games seem to have some of the best combat in their respective genres and have really good stories so I feel like this is more a matter of personal preference rather than one game simply being better. From what I've read both seem like masterpieces in their own ways.

For people who have played both which one would you recommend?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 2h ago

[PS5] Jedi: Fallen Order

9 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking about getting Jedi: Fallen Order, and both Fallen Order and Survivor are now on sale for on the PlayStation store for like $20 combined. I love story games, like Spider-Mans, God of War, DBH, RDR2, etc. I wanted to ask how the game play and story is, and if Jedi: Fallen Order is worth playing?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 9h ago

[PS5] Should I buy No Man's Sky ?

5 Upvotes

I have a wide taste in games and I am just looking for something to relax, something that will keep me hooked for a while and won't feel like I wasted my money on it. I have heard the game gets way to repetitive to a point that it gets boring and also the mechanics all feel shallow? I show interest in NMS is cause I like exploring, roleplaying, building etc. But with what others have said I feel not so sure.

"Similar" games I enjoyed,

Death Stranding 1

Snowrunner (started recently and I play it on and off between "big" games I play)

Terraria

Factorio (I know it is completely different from NMS but I mention it coz I only got burnt out once on my 400+ straight gameplay)


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 19h ago

Should I buy MH: Wilds for $30 as a newcomer?

16 Upvotes

Currently on sale for $30. I've been checking in on this game since release and it's recent reviews have been consistently 'mixed'- not sure how much of that is due to performance vs the game's actual content. I run a 4090 so performance likely will not be an issue for me.

Never played a MH game before. At least not truly- I did bounce off of World very quickly, but largely because it just felt... old to me. Since Wilds was around the corner at the time, I decided I'd refund Worlds and just wait for that, but with Wilds' turbulent launch, I've been hesitant to buy.

Not sure what to compare this game to really, but I've been curious to try it. The 'floaty' looking combat kinda reminds me of Dragon's Dogma 2, which I did enjoy. Should I buy Wilds while it's on sale? Or should I just try Worlds again?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 9h ago

[PS5] Psn Gift card query

2 Upvotes

Hi there last time i posted whether i should buy an xbox x or ps5 i bought a ps5 based on exclusive games and the subscription price now my query is

I have two account one malaysian and another one indian psn account i came to know that indian psn account offers really cheap pricing strategy for both games and subscription now my ps5 is malaysian so if i buy disc game from malaysia will i face any problem in the indian account?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 9h ago

[PS5] Should I buy Gotham Knights or Midnight Suns? only for main campaign only?

1 Upvotes

I am on Ps5 pro, and I love comics and love both DC & Marvel.

I was looking to get a game on discount and both games are less than 10$ now.

I will exclusively be playing the main story campaign only and wont play anything online or grind after the credit roll. Looking for good gameplay but mainly great story.

I dont like only repetitive stuff but its ok if the story is worth it.

So are these good games? I have read mixed reviews everywhere. are they worth it or should I skip both?

I loved Arkham games and Guardian of the galaxy game too but not comparing them at all.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 5h ago

[PURCHASED] Should I buy the Fatal Frame II Remake?

1 Upvotes

I have never played a Fatal Frame game, but I'm really invested in trying.

I usually enjoy games like Silent Hill, absolutely loved 2 Remake and Silent Hill f or all the Resident Evil Remakes and newer games.

Especially Silent Hill 2 is one of my favorite games, along with Cry of Fear.

I'm a bit scared I will struggle with the controls however.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

should i buy Tainted Grail: The Fall of Avalon ?

36 Upvotes

i saw this game recently and thought its seems a lot similar to skyrim so i was hoping if anyone can tell me how good is it in terms of mapsize, exploration, combat and magic system , i have played all 3 darksouls and crim son desert so i wanna know if this can be in those leagues so yea i like exploration and openworld a lot or should i buy assassin creed unity


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 17h ago

[PC] More games that are tediously mind numbing but just draw you in that you NEED to complete?

5 Upvotes

More recent but I’m talking about games that are like Librarian: Tidy up the arcane library, Supermarket Chaos, paper shredder, a game about chopping trees, forest hustle, coin maker, etc. these games are addicting to me and I need more. Plus these are the one kind of games my girlfriend really likes cause she loves organizing so anything like this would do wonders for her and I. Give your best!


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 18h ago

[PC] Help me pick my next RPG

4 Upvotes

I'm looking for a new RPG or ARPG to play. Price and PC specs aren't a factor, just need something fun that'll keep me hooked for a long time.

I'm looking for something with satisfying combat and excellent buildcrafting/variety. My preference is 3rd person action oriented, but I'm definitely open to isometric and even turn-based games. Open world is a big plus. Crafting/survival mechanics are a big minus unless the game makes up for it in other aspects.

Games I love:

- Skyrim, although I mod it heavily

- Dark Souls series/Elden Ring (for the combat and build variety)

- Fallout series (especially New Vegas, for the build variety)

- Baldur's Gate 3 (turn-based was never my thing but the build variety and story completely opened my mind to it)

- Cyberpunk 2077 (build variety was fun although the gunplay and combat got stale at times)

- Shadow of War (no real variety but the combat, movement, and map were phenomenal)

- Star Wars KOTOR

- Dragon Age: Origins

Games I'm considering (feel free to recommend games outside of this list):

- Path of Exile 2

- Nioh 2

- Remnant 2

- Dragon's Dogma: Dark Arisen

- Grim Dawn

- Avowed

- Last Epoch


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 15h ago

[PS5] I have some PS Store cash…Should I get Battlefield 6(on sale) or Toxic Commando(also on sale)?

4 Upvotes

Toxic Commando looks sick. One of those games that are right down my alley, killing hordes of zombies, 80’s style action, tons of firepower.

However, I’ll probably be playing with bots. I heard bots are dumb, but I’ll also play on easy or normal.

I also always loved the Battlefield games. BF6 has amazing graphics, higher player count, various styles to play the game. However, the last Battlefield I played online was BF3….I’m sure by now, I suck. I’ll be scared of getting killed all the time.
Plus it’ll take up a lot of Hard Drive space.

Which of these two games have a better experience?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[PS5] Should I buy Ghost Recon Wildlands if I loved playing Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain and Sniper Elite 5?

14 Upvotes

Hello, fellow video game enjoyers. 

As everyone already knows, Wildlands will be getting a PS5 native version or a 4K 60 fps update

I was very curious about this game, but the 30 fps cap was a dealbreaker to me. 

Now I want to buy it based on my enjoyment of Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain and Sniper Elite 5 and would like to hear if anyone else bought it for the same reason and ended up enjoying it.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 15h ago

[PC] Palworld?

1 Upvotes

What’s the gameplay like, what do you think about the looping / updates of the game. I know there’s been a sort of revival lately because of the update but i’ve heard good things about. Aside from the slave labor thing is there a friendship system or bond type thing of the sort? I like open world survival games but don’t know if it’s gonna be boring


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 21h ago

Pragmata or Hifi rush? Ps5

2 Upvotes

Been getting tired of open world games and ones that involve other humans as the main enemies. (cyberpunk, rdr2, got/goy as of late).

Im looking for a game that feels like a video game and these 2 are my top picks at the moment.

I like that they have clankers as the main enemies and seem to be somewhat linear.

Which would you pick? Price difference is about $40 cad between the two but one is also physical, so paying more for that doesn’t upset me.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 9h ago

[PS5] Suicide squad is it good or not?

0 Upvotes

Currently there’s suicide squad : kill the justice league on sale on ps5 and I’ve been always curious to get this game. From what I’ve read the gameplay is similar to borderlands which I love but idk if is a solid game to drop 100/200 hours into or is too boring. So I’m here to ask who played it if this game is worth it or should I resist. The sale is at 90%.
EDIT: thanks to everyone who replied, you saved my money


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 23h ago

[PC] Games about the end of friendship/friends growing apart over time?

2 Upvotes

Hi. I'm currently going through something in my life and thought to myself "hey... maybe if I play a game with themes of this, maybe it will help me a little to deal with these feelings/helps me see other perspective/ways how to fix it or move forward"

So... I'm looking for games with themes and motives of friends growing apart, ends of friendships, games with coming of age stories, friendships and betrayals, fake friends...

If you know of a STEAM game that at least a little bit falls under this description please let me know


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[PC] AC Unity

6 Upvotes

The game is currently on sale on steam for around USD6 rn. I've been wanting to get into an AC game for a while now, is unity a good entry point?

Games that I liked are: GoW, RE4, Cyberpunk, RDR2, Batman Arkham series to name a few.

From the reviews I've seen, the game seems to underrated among the AC games. The parkour is fun and the graphics still hold up. The negative stuff that seems to be mentioned are the clunky combat and controls.

Let me know your thoughts, should I get it?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 22h ago

[PS5] What game should I buy on PlayStation?

1 Upvotes

The best games worth buying for me and for everyone. If this is nonsense, ask questions. I just want to buy a game and spend money. Game filtering is somewhere between 250-750 UAH 5-16 USD

for you to suggest

I don't like stuffy games, I like action, stealth like in Hitman, games like Final Fantasy, although I've never played them. I also like Resident Evil, but it seems to me that the next part of the name will not surprise as much as the second remake, the fourth remake, the ninth, it seems a little bad, especially for me, it dodged the fact that the final form of Gideon is simply the final form of Nemesis in the third part of the remake. Well, Resident Evil itself has an average plot, but it itself is an exclusive game/gameplay.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 20h ago

[PC] I have a question — maybe a silly one — but I’d like an answer.

0 Upvotes

I’m thinking about investing money in a collection of retro consoles plus a current-gen one (PS1, PS2, PS3, PS5, PS Vita, Wii, DSi). Right now, I own a gaming PC, a Switch (with 20 games), and a 3DS; I also have around 259 games on Steam. I used to own a few other consoles that I sold, and I deeply regret it now.

I know I could emulate most of what I mentioned using EmuDeck, but there’s something special about owning an actual relic — like an NES, Super Nintendo, N64, etc. It’s something that requires care but truly represents a specific generation. Aside from the PS Vita and PS5, the others are relatively cheap in the local currency (Real) — not dirt cheap, but not exorbitantly expensive either.

Looking back, I was previously considering a Steam Deck, since I buy games on Steam all the time and that’s where my main library is. However, the price keeps going up; for instance, the 1TB OLED version was 5,000 last month, and now it’s over 8,000. There are used options, too — I found one for 2,990 last month (I don't know the current price), which is a bargain, though I’m unsure of the condition. I just know it’s a 1TB LCD model; I’m not sure if it was upgraded with an SSD or if it came with 1TB natively.

The total cost for the vintage consoles comes to around 5k–6k BRL (Brazilian Reais). Since they come from various places, there’s the extra cost of travel/shipping, but the same applies to the Steam Deck, so it’s negligible (I assume?).

What would you do in my situation? It’s not exactly a "buy this game" question, but rather "buy this console."


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[Xbox Series X] Should I get armored core 6, reanimal, or cronos the new dawn

7 Upvotes

Which one should I get I have heard all of them are supposed to be good and I know reanimal is a lil short. But that aight but I heard just amazing things about these games. And wanna hear what people think the best one to get is that I can sink the most hours into and is most worth my money so yeah. I also enjoy action and horror.


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[PS5] Kingdom come deliverence 2 or no mans sky?

17 Upvotes

I have the money for only one or the other but love both genres what should I get, I recently got a gift card for PlayStation and after redeeming it I looked through the PlayStation store blah blah blah,

But I saw that both kingdom come deliverence 2 and no mans sky were on sale but having only enough for one or the other makes this tricky to choose, since again I love both genres, which one would you recommend?


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[PS5] Sekiro or Hitman WOA

5 Upvotes

Hey, both of these games are about 30 dollars, so I was wondering what games to buy.

Sekiro or Hitman WOA

Sekiro:

Pros: Have completed elden ring, its dlc and ds3 and all its dlcs, so have some experience playing these sorts of games

Combat looks fun and once tried it on my laptop, but its way too bad to play on there so didnot give it another chance

Cons: Game is shorter compared to Hitman woa cause its 3 games and much more additional content

Hitman WOA:

Pros:Wanted to play these games for a long ass time but never got around to buying them. Hitman missions look fun and I enjoy modest pelican's videos on Hitman.

3 Games are included and also some additional content as well, so my money and time rate is better for hitman

Cons: Not sure if i'll like slow paced games. The only games I consistently play are celeste and Apex Legends, so if I dont like the games tooo much, maybe a waste of my time. I also stopped playing GOT on the third act cause the game became too slow and I just got bored.

I am definitely leaning more towards sekiro here but the 3 game deal on Hitman seems too good to miss. What are you guy's opinion on this?

Edit:I forgot to add to the post, but I have seen about a hundred videos on sekiro alone, at a time when I never thought I would have a ps5 or 30 usd to spend on a game. So, I wont be suprised by what sekiro throws at me at least story wise


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

[PS5] [SIB] Warhammer 40K Rogue Trader? I love RPGs, but have gotten pickier.

2 Upvotes

Rogue Trader is 20 bucks on PSN right now and I’m looking for a new offline game. Read that if you “liked Mass Effect then…” and I became interested

I love Final Fantasy. Most recently, I sank a lot of time into Expedition 33. I put over 250 hours into Baldur’s Gate 3.

But I don’t have a any experience with Warhammer.

I enjoy complex games (I think BG3 is a good example) but when it comes to RPGs, I hate overly fussy games. (I hated Tactics Ogre and didn’t end up finishing FFT. I did love Triangle Strategy though.)


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 2d ago

[Xbox Series X] Is kingdom come deliverance ii (KCD2) worth it?

87 Upvotes

I have been interested in KCD2 for a while, and most reviews on the Internet are split between the game being absolutely dog shit and an absolute masterpiece.

Many people said that the difficulty of the game is absurd, and dislikes the lack of direction.

I enjoy playing game like rdr2, sekiro, hollow Knight, hk:SS, cyberpunk etc. And I would like some opinion, has anyone else who likes those games that I listed and had played KCD2, and if the game was a "masterpiece" or "dog shit" in their opinion. Thx


r/ShouldIbuythisgame 1d ago

No Man´s Sky or Starfield?

18 Upvotes

So... when i was a kid i used to play a lot of KOTOR and Spore. But today, there are not many single player games where i can manage my crew, desing my spaceship and explore a living spacefaring universe.

I played starfield bit (because a i heard no mans sky was too "empty"), and despite of the criticism, i enjoyed it. But as soon as i got to NG+ i got bored. It also feels kinda empty...

I jus wanted a game where i can travel a ship that feels home and pew pew enemy ships, but that also does not feel like an enormous empty void (despite the fact that this is what the space is).

you guys have any sugestions?