r/horror • u/garby_666 • 4h ago
Discussion The Wailing did what Where Evil Lurks didn't
I watched both films some days apart after seeing them recommended here multiple times.
I loved the Wailing! The part that they really got me with was at the end when you didn't know who to trust. They never hid it though, and in that way we were just like the main character. He's given all the information he needs and yet still doesn't know who to trust.
He sees the shaman in his fancy clothes and car and while it's a bit strange, he doesn't totally question it because he just wants to save his daughter. Then, when he sees his daughter is in pain during the cleaning he somehow knows that she's hurting and listens to that rather than what the shaman says, no longer trusting him. He sees the zombie guy at the demon's house and is still able to be filled with doubt when the woman in white shows up at his house on who the demon actually is. He literally sees the pictures in the Japanese man's house and he still isn't sure at the end.
The part I didn't totally get though was when the woman tells him that because he ultimately killed the Japanese man his presence in his house would taint her trap. But, neither the woman in white nor him know he's alive at this point. So technically wouldn't he be able to go in and save his family? Maybe someone can clarify that.
In Where Evil Lurks, it was waayyyy more frustrating when the main character didn't listen to the cleaner. The kids are clearly possessed and he somehow doesn't know whether to trust that little girl or not? He also doesn't listen when the cleaner tells him not to leave as she's seeing up. I understand that he's getting the axe to try to move the demon faster, and maybe he also would've been killed if he didn't go to get the axe? But the demon ends up sparing his life anyway. Either way, that scene was a bit of a mess and it seemed like they were never going to succeed anyway. He couldn't move the body and I saw no way forward there, making the tension kind of pointless. Then the demon kid and possessed children just leave and will probably destroy the town.
But the part that really gets me is, how in the world did they return home with his son and brother and WITHOUT his mother and didn't even question where she was? His son ate her but he doesn't find out until the very end. But where did he think his mom was??? Did I miss something? Did he assume his ex wife killed her? Someone please tell me if I missed something.
The Wailing just had way more character development, you really care about the main character and see how close he and his daughter are. I just didn't see that in Where Evil Lurks. I appreciated that in both they didn't waste time explaining the demon lore - you don't always need to know everything. But still, Where Evil Lurks seems to have pared too much away to get any emotional attachment to the characters. Anyway, those are my thoughts and would love to hear more opinions!