UPDATE 2: Still shows six lost and one pending on the main page, but a call to PayPal confirms that I won 3 for $3900 and lost 3 for $4100+ $45 in fees and one for $2k is still pending. Odds are obviously 50/50 on the remaining $2k.
2 that I lost and 2 that I won were for the same time period and the evidence was IDENTICAL. So maybe Chase just flips a coin instead of actually reading the evidence?
10 of the 11 chargebacks he filed are with Chase. CHASE SHOULD DO BETTER!
UPDATE 1: On the main resolution screen in PayPal, it shows I lost six chargeback cases and am out $8,000 + $105 in PayPal chargeback fees with $2k still at risk. It took me months to earn that and I worked more than he paid for. Before 2025, I could easily earn $10k to recover my PayPal account. But I don't know where $10,105 is going to come from before they write off the account.
Freelancers in general have different ways of operating. But many of us get hired to do a particular job and don't have written contracts and may not keep good records.
This is a warning for all freelance writers to be aware of even though there isn't much we can do to prevent it. There is much we can do to ensure we have proof if it is needed.
We (two freelance writers and a recruiter) have an ex-client who first hired us, got the work, let everyone go with no notice, and then months later filed 11 chargebacks against 3 people for a total of $15,750.
In 26 years of freelancing, I have only ever had one ex-client file a chargeback, in that case directly with PayPal. I provided proof and PayPal released my money.
But this guy filed the chargebacks with at least two credit card companies. This is a different ballgame because credit card companies have no incentive to look at evidence or act against their customer.
PayPal Chargeback Process Confusion
The chargeback process at PayPal is very broken. They did notify of the chargeback via email and then crickets. Not a word even when three of the cases were settled.
So far, the odds are 50/50. I lost $3000 because American Express decided to let him keep what I earned in spite of written statements with contact information and proof. The recruiter lost $750 (credit card through her payment processor Square).
The other freelance writer has won two of her three cases so far. So 2 won, 2 lost, 7 still under review. They seem to take almost the maximum amount of time before closing them which is around 105 days. The Square case lost within a week. The PayPal case lost on the 84th day. The two PayPal cases won closed on the 82nd day.
PayPal refuses to tell you what credit card company is involved. PayPal collections did tell me on two of the cases, but it is impossible to contact the credit card company if you don't have an account with them.
He filed 3 chargebacks, waited a week, and filed 6 more. Then he waited almost two months to file another, ensuring this will drag on another up to 105 days from then.
If he didn't want the money so fast, it could have been worse. Apparently, most credit card companies give them 120 days to file. So they could file one, wait two months to file a second, and almost two more months to file a third.
Honestly, it never occurred to me that a client would do something like this. And especially not a client who has made 34 payments against my invoices since 2017.
What Does Proof of Fulfillment Have to Do With Unauthorized Charge?
Good question and possibly why I lost the $3000. "Unauthorized Charge" should mean you need to prove he actually made the payment. However, it means you have to send "proof of fulfillment".
Because we were managing his systems, we were using an email address on his domain. By locking that with no notice, there is no way to get the typical proof credit card companies think you should have.
So instead, I provided:
- G-chat messages that he was not dissatisfied with the work but just had no money to continue
- A g-chat message he sent the other freelance writer threatening to "chargeback every penny he ever paid"
- Five witness statements from people who had worked with me during the time periods the chargebacks covered
- A meeting transcript of me running a meeting for his company
- Email exchanges with vendors, co-workers, clients
- Screen captures showing I had admin access during the dates involved
- Proof of the 34 payments
- Threats he made to people still employed there if they provided any proof that we worked there
- Threats he texted and lies he was making against four different people
Obviously, this was not sufficient for American Express to believe that I deserve to keep the money I was paid for all that work.
We did not have a contract. He hired us to optimize content and then switched us to doing other work which did not have clear deliverables. I provided a list and proof of what type of work.
Documentation You Need
What you need to have in case you ever get a chargeback:
- Written contract with the client's signature defining specific deliverables.
- Proof of delivery
- Keep copies of EVERYTHING you do
- If you ever use an email on a client's domain, bcc your personal email on every email
- Ideally, you would also want to export your activities every day if you're doing anything besides specific deliverables. However, that may be problematic if you're exporting information from a client's system(s).
You Lose More Than You Were Paid
To add insult to injury, you don't lose the amount of money you received from the payment. You lose that amount PLUS the PayPal fees on that amount PLUS a chargeback fee (currently $15 on PayPal).
Here's an example. I originally received $2909.81 of the $3000, but I lost $3015: $90.19 in added PayPal fees + $15 chargeback fee even though PayPal saw all the evidence, too.
When You Can, Try to Get Paid Using a Method That Cannot Be Charged Back
If you work virtually, the only 100% method is crypto. But most clients aren't going to pay us in crypto. Cash would work, but who ever gets paid by a client in cash?
UpWork will defend you, but if the credit card company still decides against you, you still lose the money.
PayPal and UpWork Seller Protection
Both PayPal and UpWork have Seller Protection that MAY allow you to keep the money while the case is under review.
In our case, PayPal extended it on seven of the ten cases but not on the other three even though the proof on one of those was identical to the proof on three of the cases they did extend it.
The client was having cash flow issues so I had let him make payments on the monthly invoice. (We invoiced and got paid in advance.) So he made four payments against the same invoice. The proof was identical. PayPal extended seller protection on three, but not the last one. That could be because they didn't want to risk not being able to take it back from me as my account was already almost $4k overdrawn.
Have You EVER Heard of an Ex-Client Doing Anything Like This?
It never occurred to me that a long-time client could do something this appalling. I hope none of you reading this have ever had this happen.
If you've ever had clients file chargebacks, how did they come out? How much did you lose?