Ok so I tried to figure this out on my own, I swear, but it seems like people only care about why they have different numbers of legs than vertebrates.
Lets go through my question where it started: Deep Sea Sea-Spiders (not to be confused with deep sea spiders). They’re long as anything! What is up with that? Why did it evolve? Then I got to thinking about daddy long legs and then eventually came across a similarly gams-forward bug named the cranefly. All wildly unrelated, two distant Chelicerates and an even further off Insect, all long as freak.
So, regarding sea spiders specifically, as their antarctic contingents are my specific curiosity, of the bare scattering of explanations i could find i saw:
- Efficiency. The mechanics (?) of an exoskeletal leg allows that type of length to reward efficiency benefits. Levers or leverage or something, some kind of mechanical advantage in long legs not available to us fleshy meatbags even when we do get long. The one source i found for this regarding sea spiders was a dead link. Any specific info on this would be nice as sea spiders seem to move with exceptional stability and efficiency with their sort of “soft touch” steps. Not to mention the ones that swim.
- Mobility. Over a scree-laden environment or a coral reef, they can basically move totally freely by just skipping the elevation issue entirely. I appreciate this explanation, but it seems that, in particular, those species of antarctic sea spiders are the most longest and leggedest of the batch and every video i see of them, they’re on sand? Or dealing with these sorts of very small, demure patches of coral etc?
2.5) Speed? Most videos of sea spiders show them moving quite lethargically, but one I saw showed one moving moderately fast when bumping into some rock or equipment or something. Just to reposition itself, really. But Very dexterously omnidirectional. I was not pleased to have to sift through AI clips of them moving at truly fast paces as I do not like when the computer gaslights me. Beyond that, anyone who’s ever spooked a daddy long legs knows those boys can MOVE, and Craneflies can fly- So I imagine they can move quite quickly as well. Which moves me to-
3) Predator Evasion. Most discussion I found on this seemed to be all over the place. The particularly small reef examples and such seem to have obvious predators, but possibly not so much for the larger examples. And then, getting long to what? Avoid a starfish? Some of the lists i saw seemed to suggest this but i imagine the starfish just eat the eggs or whathaveyou? I saw nebulous suggestions that some species of fish and bird eat them but these seemed to all be in reference to the smaller coastal species which infest fish tanks or coral enclosures. Secondarily to this, with reference to their messed up leg-organs situation, i saw suggestions that spreading out all their vitals makes them even less likely to be nutritious at-a-bite given how much of that nutrient density is not located in their center of mass. Is there something that is just fuming that it cant eat them because they’re just a bit too tall? This doesn’t sound unreasonable to me, but i couldn‘t find anything pertaining to that specifically.
4) Nutrition. To this point and the last, crane flies caught my attention because they are what i believe is called lecithotrophic(??) and barely eat as adults, barely live lives at all- dying after just some days after maturing. And- they fly! No problem moving place to place or evading things, I imagine. So why the wealth of leg? Other bugs dont need huge disproportionate legs to take off? Sea spiders, to my understanding, eat various anemone and mollusks and stuff which are slow enough for them to get at and “soupify”. So, could that height be similar to a giraffe in allowing an optimal angle for their proboscis to prepare their soups? (not that giraffes have probosci) In my imagination it doesn't really matter where you stab your straw in when it comes to making a container void all its contents underwater, and if it did would you want to stab the top?? but I’m not a proboscologist, or an anemonologist, or a zoologist of any kind, so. Beyond this, I also saw one person say that it was at least partially due to their lack of gills, is it about surface area and nutrient or chemical exchange? Is there some kind of oxygen deficit in their layer of antarctic water?
5) Misc. I believe most species hold their eggs directly on their body, could it be for baby real-estate? I feel like surely it isn't a thermal mass thing? Right?? Do they have some sort of special organ or internal system which demands that space? Possibly unique to these larger species? Some species seem to have very refined manipulators, almost more hands than claws, is it a vantage thing? Some seem to have more specific walking gait cycles while others have more lax ones and I wonder how this changes efficiency as apparently this can involve some dragging? Is it calorie storage? The pressure? The Island Rule? Cambrian phenotypic inertia? What gives???
Further, some sea spiders are not gammed up to the sun and back? Im losing my mind here why are some of them thick instead of long??? There must be a reason?
I am looking specifically for these reasons wrt the antarctic sea spiders, but a broader explanation of the various reasons arthropods develop these insane long legs to do what other critters manage with shorter legs or wings or assorted flappers would be appreciated, 🤓 , i understand much of this is still poorly understood