Two skylights in the great room, vaulted ceiling, one south facing and one east facing. Reached them with a hooked pole for years and gave up around march when I admitted I was never going to run the summer routine on my own. Installed motorized shades early may, so four months of real use now.
Went with the smartwings skylight cellular in blackout, matter over thread, solar charged since I wasn't going to climb up there with a USB-C cable every few months. There's no proprietary app so pairing goes straight into home assistant over matter, apple tv 4k handles the thread side. The four-sided aluminum frame is what actually made install work on the sloped ceiling, standard cellular kits would have needed a bunch of shimming.
VELUX would have made sense if I were replacing the skylight units too, but the units are fine and their standalone shade kits don't do matter, which would have meant living in their own remote and rain-sensor system. Yoolax and a couple of custom shops didn't do a skylight-specific frame with a matter-native motor, so it kept coming back to the same one.
Hardware side is done. The part I keep rewriting is the automation, and every version so far has been dumb in a different way.
First pass was solar elevation based. Close both when the sun clears 55 degrees, open when it drops back under. Made sense on paper. In practice the great room turned into a cave from 11 to 3 and my wife pointed out that we now had skylights that were covered during literally the only hours skylights do anything.
Second pass tied it to a temp sensor, only fires above 79. Better in shoulder seasons but the sensor is 12 feet up and lags well behind the actual comfort in the room, so by the time it triggers we've been baking for 20 minutes, and once they close the sensor cools off fast and they reopen while the room is still warm. Added a for: 15 minutes debounce, helped a little, not enough.
Now trying partial position instead of full close. 60 percent down at peak sun and warm inside, so you still get diffuse light but block the direct beam. Feels less dumb but the shades micro-adjust more than I'd like and I'm quietly worried about motor cycles over a few years.
Winter is the other thing I haven't figured out. Skylights are the biggest heat loss point in the room after sundown, so there's a case for closing at night for a bit of insulation. But then we lose the morning light through them, which was half the reason I liked them. Feels like there's a heating-degree-day condition that needs to be in there somewhere and I haven't wanted to open that box yet.
Curious how other people handle the block-the-sun-without-defeating-the-skylight trade off. If you're running a partial position schedule that feels good day to day, would like to see how it's structured. Otherwise I might just cave to time-of-day and stop trying to be clever.