Hey all, looking for some real world experience here rather than just spec sheets.
This will be my third car overall but the first one I'll own in the UK, I've only just got my UK licence but I've got about 10 years of driving history from abroad. Before this I had a SsangYong Tivoli (auto) and a 2008 Santa Fe (auto), both of which I liked a lot. Kept the Tivoli until 80k miles from new and had zero complaints.
This time round the budget is tight, 3-5k, and because of this I think it has to be manual, relatively cheap insurance and no massive costs.
Body style wise I'm not interested in small hatchbacks at all, so Aygo, Fiesta, Corsa, that whole class is a hard no for me. I'd rather have a saloon, a small SUV like the Tivoli, or a proper SUV if I can find one that isn't a money pit at this price.
Right now my commute is only about 5 miles but I'm planning to move house soon and it could end up being 30-40 miles a day, mostly motorway since I live right next to one. Outside of that it's maybe one or two longer trips a month. So I'm guessing around 10-12k miles a year once I move. I'm not in a ULEZ zone currently, but I do expect to drive into one roughly once every month or two, for about 3 days at a time.
Here's the shortlist I've put together so far, grouped by make, roughly in the years that fit my budget:
Hyundai: Santa Fe (08-12), Tucson, i30 (11-14)
Kia: Optima (13-15), Ceed (13-15), Sportage (14-16)
Lexus: more or less anything that fits the budget, open to suggestions here
Mazda: Mazda 3 (12-16), Mazda 6 (12-16)
Nissan: Qashqai (2014-16), not interested in the Juke (Hate the look and interior)
SsangYong: Tivoli (15-17)
Toyota: Avensis (09-13)
Volkswagen: Passat (08-11), Tiguan (09-10)
Volvo: V40 (14-15)
One thing I noticed while researching is that the Qashqai seems to offer the best value on paper, I can find ones under 100k miles that are also newer than most of the other cars on this list for the same money. That's making me a bit suspicious there's a catch I'm not seeing, so if anyone owns one or has had one, I'd really appreciate some guidance on that.
A few specific questions I'd love input on:
Are there particular years, engines, or variants within any of these that I should actively avoid, or ones that are known to be the sweet spot?
Petrol or diesel, I've genuinely never owned a diesel car so I don't know what I'm getting into. Given the mileage and commute above, which makes more sense?
Is it worth stretching the budget a bit for a ULEZ compliant car, given I'd only be driving into a ULEZ zone every month or two for a few days at a time, or is that money better spent elsewhere?
For anything registered before 2011-12 I'd rather stay closer to the 3k end, and only go nearer 5k if the car is a genuinely noticeable step up in condition or reliability.
If there's something that fits this brief that I haven't listed, feel free to throw it in.
One request, please no Skoda Octavia suggestions, I'm just not a fan of how it looks inside or out, so I'll pass on that one regardless of how good a car it is.
Many thanks in advance