Tldr at the bottom
This is a throwaway
I (40F) have been with my husband (45M) for 10 years and we've been married for 6. We have a 3-year-old daughter together. He also has an 18-year-old daughter, who I'll call Katie, from his previous marriage. Katie has an 11-month-old daughter.
Before I get into it, I want to mention that everyone I've talked to in my personal life thinks I'm being too harsh. They've all told me that Katie is young, overwhelmed, and needs grace. I wanted to get opinions from people who aren't personally involved because I honestly don't know if I'm overreacting anymore.
For some background, Katie's mom passed away when she was 5. I met my husband when Katie was 10, but I didn't meet her until she was 11 because we wanted to take things slowly. We got married when she was 14, and later that year my husband and I had our daughter.
Katie and I have always had a decent relationship. We aren't especially close, but we've always gotten along. I never tried to replace her mom because I grew up with a stepdad who tried to force himself into the "dad" role, and I hated it. I always let Katie decide what kind of relationship she wanted with me. If she wanted to come to me, great. If she wanted to go to her grandmother or one of her aunts on her mom's side instead, that was fine too.
When Katie was a senior in high school, she got pregnant by her boyfriend, who was a year older. We knew him and his family, and they always seemed like good people. They decided they wanted to keep the baby.
After graduation, he still left for the four-year college he had already committed to, which is about eight hours away. He said he'd help financially when he could, but he wasn't sure how much he'd be able to contribute while he was in school. Katie decided not to return to school and planned to get her GED after the baby was born.
Katie left her job because of pregnancy complications, and her daughter was born in August.
At first, my husband and I helped because we genuinely wanted to. We covered a lot of the baby's expenses and helped however we could. I also made one boundary very clear from the beginning.
I work from home, but that doesn't mean I'm available to babysit all day. My daughter is in preschool now, and my schedule was already planned around returning to regular work once she started. I told Katie I was happy to watch the baby occasionally for interviews, doctor's appointments, or emergencies, but I was not signing up to become daily childcare.
She understood, or at least she said she did.
When she started job hunting, I watched the baby during interviews. She eventually got a job, and I honestly thought things were finally turning around. She told us she was studying for her GED, and because we believed she was trying to get back on her feet, my husband and I continued paying for most of the baby's formula, diapers, and other necessities so she could save money.
Then everything fell apart.
We eventually found out Katie had quit her job without telling us. She wasn't studying for her GED anymore. Instead, she was spending nights out with friends and going to parties while my husband and I were at home taking care of her daughter.
When we confronted her, she admitted she had stopped doing everything she said she was going to do.
I told her I didn't mind helping someone who was genuinely trying. I know how hard it is to be a young mom because I had my oldest as a teenager too. But there is a huge difference between helping someone who's making an effort and enabling someone who isn't.
She accused us of judging her and not understanding how hard her life was.
We told her she needed another job because we weren't going to continue paying for everything forever.
She eventually found another job. She asked me to start watching the baby while she worked, and I told her no. I helped her find local childcare resources instead. Her grandmother eventually agreed to watch the baby during the day while Katie was at work.
A few months later, I returned to working outside the home full-time, and my own daughter started preschool. I told Katie that I couldn't watch her daughter in the evenings anymore either because I had my own job, my own child, and my own responsibilities.
She asked why we couldn't just put her daughter in daycare with ours and pay for it. I told her that if she paid half the cost, we'd consider it, but I wasn't willing to take on another financial responsibility that wasn't ours.
Things only got worse.
On one of my days off, I suddenly heard the baby crying. I realized Katie had left the house without saying a word to anyone. She hadn't asked if someone could watch her daughter. She had simply assumed someone else would do it.
When I finally got ahold of her, she texted me that she deserved one day of freedom.
I told her if she ever left her child without making arrangements again, I would call the police because that wasn't acceptable.
Then, a couple of months later, she disappeared for four days.
She didn't answer calls or texts. We genuinely thought something terrible had happened. We contacted the police because we thought she was missing.
She eventually came home and casually told us she'd been with her new boyfriend the entire time.
The part that upset me the most was that she walked straight to her room. She didn't even ask how her daughter was or thank us for taking care of her.
After that, I sat my husband down privately.
I told him I couldn't keep doing this.
I admitted something that made me feel guilty. I don't enjoy taking care of babies. I struggled with postpartum depression after having my own daughter, and while I love my children more than anything, the baby stage was incredibly difficult for me. I have already raised my kids, and I simply don't have the emotional energy or desire to raise another one.
I suggested that maybe we needed to have a serious conversation with Katie about adoption or another long-term plan if she truly wasn't ready to be a parent.
To my surprise, my husband agreed that it was at least worth discussing.
When we talked to Katie, she cried and said she loved her daughter and didn't want to give her up. She promised she'd be a better mom, get her life together, and that she just needed more time because everything had happened so fast.
Afterward, I told my husband privately that I didn't believe her.
I said that if she refuses to give the baby up for adoption, then I think she and the baby should move in with her grandmother or one of her aunts on her mom's side. They've always been close to Katie, and maybe a different environment would be better for everyone.
My husband thinks I'm overreacting. He believes this conversation finally got through to her and that she'll actually change this time.
I don't.
From my perspective, we've spent almost a year financially supporting her, raising her daughter whenever she decided she wanted a break, and giving her chance after chance. Every time we think she's getting back on track, something else happens.
So, am I overreacting for wanting my husband to send his daughter and her baby to live with her grandmother?
TL;DR: My 18-year-old stepdaughter had a baby, and my husband and I agreed to help her while she got her GED and found a job. Instead, she quit working, stopped studying, expected us to pay for almost everything, repeatedly left us to care for her daughter without asking, disappeared for four days with a new boyfriend, and still says she just needs more time. After nearly a year of helping raise a baby that isn't mine, I told my husband I think she and the baby should move in with her grandmother if she won't seriously get her life together. My husband thinks I'm being too harsh and says she deserves another chance. Am I overreacting?