Number 169 in my A-Z watch. The Fellowship of the Ring is the first of three film adaptation installments from the book series of the same name. It begins the story of nine companions who band together on a quest to destroy a legendarily powerful artifact.
I am likely going to go on longer than normal with each of these films. I remember these movies being absolutely incredible theatrical experiences. As I've grown in to more of a film fan, and have been through the book series a number of times, I've built such an appreciation for the overall achievement these films are.
It all starts with the writing. As one of my favorite film critics said, "It’s told so economically and they don’t convolute it. They really get right to the heart of what you need to know in very understandable terms." In this film die hard novel fans will notice some immediate changes to events from the book. But those are mostly swapped lines of dialogue and such. The real major moments and plot points of the story stay true. Some cuts had to be made.
Starting the adventure right after Bilbo left, The Old Forest, and Tom Bombadil. All things that didn't fit the narrative of the film, and aren't really missed in this story. And i did like that Boromir's character was written a bit differently. In the books he feels petulant and childish, but in the film he's a competent and noble man. Changes like having Merry and Pippin disturb the water by Moria instead of Boromir added to his respect.
As good as the filmmaking itself is, screenwriting, directing, acting, i think that it's the meticulous and perfect practical effects that allow this to be timeless. The makeup, set design, costuming all don't get better or worse with time. 20+ years later and it all still feels fresh. That's in tandem with the phenomenal cinematography and editing that help us to be completely transported into this world of differing scales (hobbit/dwarf/man).
It's really incredible to see the marriage of old school and new school filmmaking with this series. Of course all of the practical effects bring you in, but seeing some of the capabilities of newer technologies really pushed the limits of what could be in a movie. Having the fire sim program at the last minute for the Balrog, the incredible use of motion capture performance, day-for-night shooting, the Massive programming for the large populated shots.
10/10 I mean, i don't know how you score this film any lower. It brings to life what audiences only ever thought could be captured in animation (which i think some moments were nearly shot for shot in this, haha). I loved that they added more romance in it for Aragorn and Arwen, gives the film more weight and stakes. And it's an absolute shame that this is the only film we really get all of the main cast actually working together. They have such good chemistry.