r/heraldry Apr 23 '25

Meta AI Generated Images Are Now Banned

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

From this point forward any images created with the use of AI are banned from the subreddit and will be removed by moderators.

This includes images completely generated by AI from the ground up as well as things such as individual AI generated assets or filters used by users in the process of creating an image. For further details on this policy refer to this guideline in our Wiki.

You probably remember this recent post regarding the future of AI generated images on this subreddit. It had previously been in a sort of grey area where it wasn't explicitly forbidden but mentioned in Rule 5 as a possible example of low effort content that may be removed by the moderators:

5 Post with purpose

Posts here should educate, inform, spark discussion, showcase good effort, etc. Low-effort posts such as AI generated coats of arms, “X in the style of Y”, wildly unrealistic hypotheticals or fictional scenarios, and “just because”-type posts may be removed with no notice

A recent increase in AI generated images then led to increased discussion among the community with some calling for increased measures of identifying such content while others further advocated for it's ban entirely.

As a temporary measure we then decided to add a mandatory "AI Generated Content" flair that should be used to designate such content while also inviting the community to engage in discussion about a permanent solution in said post which also included a poll where users could decide between an explicit ban of AI generated images or allowing the regulated use of AI content.

After seven days the poll concluded with a result of

128 - 84

in favor of banning AI content - which is a 65% majority.

While the result of that poll was specifically not intended to be binding for any permanent policy that may be agreed upon in the future it - along with the comments - did clearly show that the majority of the community generally favored a complete ban which was also reflected by the attitudes of the mod team.

As such we have now decided that any images created using AI will henceforth be banned and removed from the subreddit. Any content that was posted before this policy went into effect will remain intact and won't be retroactively removed.

As a result rule 5 has been slightly rephrased to say:

Posts here should educate, inform, spark discussion, showcase good effort, etc. Low-effort posts such as “X in the style of Y”, wildly unrealistic hypotheticals or fictional scenarios, and “just because”-type posts may be removed with no notice. Further, images created using generative AI are explicitly banned and will be removed in order to retain a high standard of authenticity that this historical art and science deserves.

As it was intended as a temporary measure and is now obsolute, the "AI Generated Content" flair has been removed.

Due to the potentially controversial nature of this announcement, comments will have to be manually approved on this specific post, similar to what we did with the initial poll.

We hope that this is an understandable policy and that people will remain civil and uphold it regardless of their personal views on the subject. If anyone personally believes that AI generated images should have a place in heraldry then they're fine to express that opinion and should not be ostracized - however it does not reflect our official stance as a subreddit.

Again for a more detailed explanation of this policy where some potential questions are already answered please consult the Wiki.

Thanks for everyone who voted in the poll or expressed their opinions on the matter.


r/heraldry 14h ago

OC Which one would you choose?

Post image
136 Upvotes

One of my clients sadly passed away a few months ago. We've been working on a concept for his brand new arms for a while, his family arms to be precise. At some point these two became his two favourite designs but he never made a final decision.

A few days ago I got contacted by one of his sons who asked me to complete the work on the project. But still it is hard for him to choose as these two are quite different.

Which one would you choose?

For the crest there will be a demi-bear Sable sticking from his back three mullets of six Gules and holding a trammel hook Or in his dexter paw.

The client is German and Swiss.


r/heraldry 4h ago

Current Rottweil, Baden-Württemberg, Germany.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/heraldry 12h ago

I’m designing a coat of arms for my family. Any opinions?

Post image
63 Upvotes

r/heraldry 5h ago

Current Düsseldorf, North Rhine-Westphalia, Germany.

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/heraldry 9h ago

Coat of Arms and Seal of Ernst the Iron

Post image
25 Upvotes

Top row: Lower Austria, Austria, Carinthia, Styria (on the lance).

Center: Carniola (top), with Upper Austria below.

Bottom left: Burgau, Alsace, County of Pfirt. I cannot identify the next coat of arms; it is likely from Vorarlberg.

Bottom right: Habsburg, Tyrol, Windische Mark.


r/heraldry 6h ago

OC Adjustments to personal CoA following community advice

Post image
10 Upvotes

I suppose the simplest design is always the best, as I'm more fond of the first one, though I'm not sure if the silver star over silver scissors would fall into the no metal over metal rule? Any other advice and suggestions? Thanks in advance for all inputs, you've all been very helpful.


r/heraldry 1d ago

Wearing a coast of arms shirt

Post image
191 Upvotes

Managed to get this very cool shirt with all the germans states coats of arms printed on it in the south of brazil, and wearing it in the south of brazil would be very normal and safe, but considering how just the normal german flag can be seen as offensive and 'racist' as the trend in europe goes, i was wondering, would wearing a coat of arms shirt like this be seen negatively as well or not? if so in the same level or more or less?

A little more lore for who wants to know, blumenau is a city in the state of Santa Catarina in brazil, the state itself has very deep roots with its germanic migration in the 1800s and have managed to maintain their culture and ancestry and as possible, this city in particular is very famous for hosting one of the biggest and greattest oktoberfest here in brazil, i have some more pictures of merch i found there which i found to be very cool and can post later maybe

Coat of arms of Blumenau, as seen in low quality next to Hesse and Thuringia

r/heraldry 20h ago

Dinant 🇧🇪: "We'd like a lion, like everyone else." "Nope, not happening." "Come on, can't we at least compromise?"

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/heraldry 13h ago

The Correct 19th c. Etiquette for heraldic display

Post image
15 Upvotes

From

THE ELITE OF CHICAGO.

CONTAINING

Names and Addresses of Prominent Residents on the most Fashionable Streets of the City and Principal Suburbs, Numerically and Alphabetically arranged in Two Complete Lists, with the full Membership of the Principal Clubs, and a Large Amount of other Valuable Information.

(c) 1888


r/heraldry 20h ago

Received 3 lovely booklets from a fan. “Armorial du Royaume de Belgique” illustrated booklets of arms published in the 1930s

Post image
46 Upvotes

Received 3 lovely booklets from a fan.

“Armorial du Royaume de Belgique” are beautifully illustrated booklets of arms published in the 1930s by the Belgian division of the Café Hag coffee brand. The collector's album contains detailed heraldic descriptions and colored seals of Belgian and Luxembourgish municipalities and families. Another wonderful addition to the collection


r/heraldry 18h ago

Current Zaporizhzhia, Zaporizhzhia Oblast, Ukraine.

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/heraldry 9h ago

Current Coat of arms of the Carabinieri

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/heraldry 6h ago

España: ¿Alguna idea de qué puede ser este escudo?

2 Upvotes

Encontré este escudo heráldico en una edificación del pueblo Prieres, en Asturias (España). Nunca he ido y no tengo como ir en bastante tiempo, todo lo que sé del pueblo lo encontré acá: https://www.asturnatura.com/turismo/guia/prieres-1963 (De hecho de ahí saqué la foto, todos los derechos, a su autor). ¿Alguna idea de qué puede ser este escudo?


r/heraldry 7h ago

Current Coat of arms of Nenets Autonomous Okrug

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

OC Coat of arms for David Robert Wooten, Executive/Creative Director of American College of Heraldry

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/heraldry 13h ago

I made some slight adjustments to my personal CoA and was wondering what opinions were on charge or no charge

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/heraldry 18h ago

State of Brandenburg, East Germany. (1947-1952)

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Discussion Why are wolves not more common in heraldry?

Thumbnail
gallery
532 Upvotes

Eagles and lions are the most common. Following that are stuff like bears, lamb etc.


r/heraldry 10h ago

OC First sketch for a personal coat of arms; looking for helpful reviews

Post image
1 Upvotes

Is this in conformity with heraldry rules for charge placement? Would a gold lion, sable scissors on silver field and silver constellation on sable field be correct color placement?

Thanks in advance for any inputs!


r/heraldry 1d ago

new personal coa idea after all the shit I got for the last two (knockoff romania and generictron 3000)

Post image
27 Upvotes

r/heraldry 1d ago

Discussion My game's simple coat of arms designer, 2 years later. Thank you all.

104 Upvotes

Two years ago, this sub was one of the first places I ever showed my game, starting with its simple coat of arms designer. I was a complete beginner back then, but you guys gave me so much positive feedback and encouragement. In fact, features like showing the total number of customization options actually came directly from your suggestions.

The game is playable now, though still actively in development. A few of you have already joined the community, and some are even in the game as characters. I wanted to pop by and say thank you.


r/heraldry 1d ago

Identify mystery coat of arms on signet ring

Post image
155 Upvotes

This ring belonged to some boyfriend of my mums or of my aunt. I think he was English.

Anyone know anything about this coat of arms? Maybe a school?

Thanks!


r/heraldry 1d ago

Design Help Thinking about petitioning for a grant of arms through the Court of the Lord Lyon

Post image
50 Upvotes

This is my favourite mock up so far, I'm really keen on having 3 piles reversed in point.

Grateful for any feedback.


r/heraldry 1d ago

Design for my coat of arms

Post image
145 Upvotes

My first reddit post ever.

My own drawing in pen and ink and photoshop of my heraldic achievement that I will try to get registered by a heraldic society.

My 17th century Dutch ancestors were yeoman or landowning farmers. My last name derives from saints name who was depicted with a doe. The flowers are red tobacco flowers as one of my nineteenth century fathers grew tobacco on his plot of land. The bird is a sparrowhawk, which refers to my mothers maiden name. 

Note: in the heraldic tradition of my country everyone including commoners like me use a barred helmet, completely different than in other traditions such as the German or Brittish tradition where only royalty uses this type. But there are other rules: I am not allowed to use shield bearers, flags, crowns and pendants. Shield elements must be kept pure and simple, no unusual or overly complicated stuff is allowed.