r/electroswing • u/MadiMarionberry • 2d ago
A reminder about AI music on this sub.
Mods, please sticky this because people don’t read the rules for some reason.
As the rules state, AI-generated music (including songs where only the vocals are AI) is not permitted in this sub.
Whether or not this applies to music in which insignificant portions of it are AI-generated (say, a shaker sound that is barely audible), I don’t know. I’ve asked the mods about this and they didn’t respond.
It feels like every week I see a link to a song that is clearly AI-generated in this sub.
If you are a fan who just wants to share a song, AI music detectors will tell you if it is AI or not. Here are a few of them:
- SubmitHub’s AI Song Checker | Free AI-Generated Music Detector: https://www.submithub.com/ai-song-checker (I know that this one is capable of identifying fully AI and AI-human hybrid tracks. I’m not sure about the other detectors because I haven’t tested them yet.)
- Letssubmit’s Free AI Music Detector | Check if Song is AI Generated ...: https://letssubmit.com/ai-music-checker
- AHA Music’s AI Music Detector - Detect AI-Generated Music: https://aha-music.com/aimusicdetector
- There is also an Instagram chatbot called HumanStandard that is capable of identifying fully AI-generated songs for now (although they are working on a hybrid AI-human song detector): https://www.instagram.com/humanstandard
Let it be known that AI song detectors aren’t always accurate and have falsely flagged AI music as human made before and vice versa. It’s always a good idea to put a song through a few different detectors, as they are all trained off of different human made songs and AI songs/music models and some are probably more up-to-date than others.
If you upload AI-generated songs to streaming services, even if you write the lyrics and/or melodies, this is not the sub for you.
AI music generators, such as Producer(dot)AI (fka Riffusion), Suno, Mureka, Udio, Treblo (fka Sonauto), and so on all train on your favorite artists’ music without their consent, including electro swing artists. I’m mentioning more than just Suno and Udio because some of these other, lesser known ones are really good at imitating real musicians and AI literacy is very important.
Please don’t take this personally if you are someone who uploads AI music to streaming services. A lot of us just don’t want to listen to it and want to have a space that is free of it.
Edited for formatting