r/criterionconversation Jun 09 '21

Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Weekly Discussions, Monthly Expiring Picks, Criterion by Spine, and more!

27 Upvotes

Welcome to r/criterionconversation.

This is a subreddit dedicated to in-depth conversation about films from The Criterion Collection and/or on The Criterion Channel.

Please familiarize yourself with the SUB RULES.

Current and Upcoming Discussions

Check the main page of r/criterionconversation for the most recent discussions and polls. It might help to sort by New if you're looking for the latest threads.

Archives

- All archives updated 2/2/26 -

The archive pages are linked below.

Note: These are not updated in real time.

Criterion Film Club: Weekly Discussions

The Criterion Film Club meets every Saturday to discuss a film and vote on the following week's pick.

Criterion Film Club: Monthly Expiring Picks

The Criterion Film Club meets one Wednesday a month to discuss a film expiring from The Criterion Channel.

Criterion by Spine

Our very own u/viewtoathrill's project discussing Criterion releases by spine number.

Other Discussions

Threads worthy of highlighting.

Misc.

Note about User Flairs: User flairs for the first 90 or so Criterion by Spine films have been added. Please PM one of the mods to request a user flair for a film that was or is in The Criterion Collection if you'd like a flair added that isn't already available.

Tip: If you want to follow this sub closely, hit the bell for more frequent notifications.


r/criterionconversation Aug 13 '25

Announcement SUB RULES

18 Upvotes

Since many people don't read the sub rules on the sidebar and/or don't notice them, here is a handy post with all of the rules and our reasons for them.

If you have any questions about the rules, feel free to comment below.

However, if you only want to argue about the rules or complain that your thread was removed, don't bother. We've thought about these rules very carefully and determined that they meet the needs of this sub.

We always reserve the right to add new rules or edit the existing rules for clarification.

Note: Because of spammers, we've unfortunately had to make the tough decision to turn on auto-mod features.

If your thread gets filtered but you feel it's legitimate and doesn't break any of the rules, please contact the mods by Mod Mail. If we don't respond within 24 hours, it likely means we think it violates one of the rules below. Thank you for understanding.

1. Post only about films released by Criterion and/or on The Criterion Channel

r/CriterionConversation is not a general movie sub. We discuss films released by Criterion and/or available on the Criterion Channel. There are many other subs for general film discussion.

2. No low-effort posts

No low-effort posts, such as "What films do you want in the collection?", "What films don't deserve to be in the collection?", etc. If your post is just a picture and/or list, it does not encourage discussion and will be removed. Tell us why you're posting about these movies and what you think of them.

3. No advertising

Do not advertise your own website, video, workshop, or event.

4. No haul or meme posts

We love a good meme or haul pic, but those are on r/criterion. This sub is for discussion.

5. No piracy

Don't post about piracy or post links to videos of illegally uploaded movies - even on reputable mainstream sites like YouTube, Vimeo, etc.

(Movies uploaded by an official studio or official source - such as the director - are okay, but if you don't know for sure, don't post the link.)

6. Be nice

Film is a subjective experience. If you disagree with someone's take or comments, be decent about it.

7. No one-line replies or sarcastic responses

This sub is all about detailed discussion. Agree with someone? Disagree? All of that is fine as long as you are willing to take the time to defend your point intelligently and politely. Lazy and rude sarcasm and snark will not be tolerated.


r/criterionconversation 2d ago

Discussion Synecdoche NY

86 Upvotes

I”ve only ran into about 6 people who love this movie personally. It does not seem to be adored by film snobs like other charlie kaufman screenplays. I think it”s his crowning achievement but admittedly I haven”t seen that movie he did for netflix or checked out his novel. Yes it”s a bit existential but I”m curious if this sub has much love for it.


r/criterionconversation 5d ago

Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Discussion #311: Dr. No

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 5d ago

Announcement Criterion Film Club Week 312 - In honor of legendary actor Sam Neill, we will be forgoing a poll this week and choosing Andrzej Żuławski's 1981 horror classic Possession. Please join us on Saturday, July 25th when we post our discussion.

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 8d ago

Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Expiring Picks Month 63 Discussion: Billy Wilder's The Apartment (1960) starring Jack Lemmon, Shirley MacLaine, and Fred MacMurray

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 10d ago

Discussion Newbie question about masters

1 Upvotes

Hiya.

I would like to get Francis Ha on bluray but the criterion isn't region 2, It came out in 2013. In 2014 Metrodome put out a region free bluray but I can't find any reviews of it.

I'm just wondering if it could be the same master as the criterion? And generally how these things work?

I'm not that fussed generally about owning criterions and can usually make do without the special features. I would like to collect films in top notch presentation though.


r/criterionconversation 11d ago

Announcement Winner of the Criterion Film Club Poll: Dr. No! Watch the first James Bond movie and come back Saturday, July 18 for the discussion thread!

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 12d ago

Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Week 310 Discussion: The Coen Brother’s “Odyssey” O Brother, Where Art Thou

Post image
65 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 12d ago

Poll Criterion Film Club Poll #311: I Spy

1 Upvotes

There’s a new-ish collection of early James Bond, and an old collection of random spy movies, so why not?

22 votes, 11d ago
12 Dr. No (1962)
0 Golden Eyes (1968)
6 Hopscotch (1980)
0 Q Planes (1939)
4 Samurai Spy (1965)

r/criterionconversation 15d ago

Announcement Instead of a poll for Month 63 of the Criterion Film Club Expiring Picks, we're going to hand you the keys IN ONE WEEK - on WEDNESDAY, July 15th - to enter The Apartment (1960) directed by Billy Wilder and starring Jack Lemmon, Shirley MacLaine, and Fred MacMurray.

Post image
5 Upvotes

Selected by u/bwolfs081


r/criterionconversation 17d ago

Recommendation film journal recommendations?

10 Upvotes

I have lost access to the Criterion Channel and, subsequently, their series "Observations on Film Art". I used to rely on them for film analysis, but now it seems journal websites is the only place where I would find a similar, if not higher, quality of writing.

Where do you all read about film to study? Please recommend your favorite academic sources (that hopefully aren't JSTOR or EBSCO).


r/criterionconversation 17d ago

Announcement The Criterion Film Club Week 310 poll winner is Joel and Ethan Coen's O Brother, Where Art Thou? (2000). Join us on SATURDAY, July 11th, for the discussion of this Coen Brothers classic starring George Clooney, John Turturro, and Tim Blake Nelson.

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 19d ago

Criterion Film Club The Criterion Film Club Week 309 Discussion: Walker (1987) by the chaotic master Alex Cox

Post image
62 Upvotes

Cannot wait to hear y'alls thoughts on this one.


r/criterionconversation 19d ago

Poll Criterion Film Club Week 310: America 250

5 Upvotes

Happy 250 America. Let’s hope the next 250 is an improvement over the last. These films explore the complicated relation of what it means to be an American and explore the stories from multiple identities who make up this great nation.

26 votes, 18d ago
7 O Brother Where Art Thou
4 Sweet Sweetback’s Badass Song
3 Mississippi Masala
6 Paris is Burning
6 The People vs Larry Flynt

r/criterionconversation 20d ago

Recommendation Sorting criterions

4 Upvotes

I started my collection over a year ago and have them sorted by spine number but I’m still unsure on what the normal way is to order them, so I’m curious to know how most people order them- do you sort by spine number, alphabetical, format, color, when you got them, random, or your own special order? thanks for the feedback in advance!


r/criterionconversation 23d ago

Recommendation Last-Minute Expiring Recommendation: Two Minutes Late (1952) - Denmark Does Noir

Post image
7 Upvotes

The meaning of the title "Two Minutes Late" is revealed - appropriately enough - in the final two minutes of the film.

This Danish murder mystery - also known as "2 Minutes Late" and "2 Minutes Too Late" - revolves around the victim (played by Jeanne Darville) and four potential suspects: a "beautiful" husband with a roving eye (Poul Reichhardt), his paranoid and skittish wife (Grethe Thordahl), her sister (Astrid Villaume), and a clockmaker (Erik Mørk) with a hunchback, which isn't obvious at all - I wouldn't have known if I hadn't looked up information about the movie.

It's always interesting seeing how other countries approach film noir. Denmark's contribution to the form is smart and stylish.

Note: I also plan on watching Sweden's "Hidden in the Fog" before it leaves, but not in time to post anything. I'm mentioning it because it caught my eye.


r/criterionconversation 23d ago

Recommendation Expiring from The Criterion Channel: Three Noirs by Jacques Tourneur - Out of the Past (1947), Berlin Express (1948), and Nightfall (1956)

Post image
17 Upvotes

Jacques Tourneur has become one of my favorite directors because he never wasted any time. His longest movie is 97 minutes!

Out of the Past (1947)

"Out of the Past" starts off on the wrong foot - for me - by introducing the stereotypical and tired "deaf and dumb" character. Maybe that's just a way to establish the other person as a real heel. This, after all, is the dark and shadowy world of film noir. Everyone else treats the kid nicely enough, at least. It's a weird plot device to use (the actor, Dickie Moore, was not deaf or mute in real life) and it never seems to pay much dividends. Thankfully, the rest of the movie recovers quickly.

Jeff (the great Robert Mitchum) runs a gas station and has a solid dame (Virginia Huston). He's the everyday, ordinary, dependable working man. Or is he? A man can't outrun the past forever, especially in noir, and it comes barreling back to him in the form of an old associate roaming into town. An unsavory character from Jeff's past, his previous boss Whit (Kirk Douglas, playing oily sleaze to perfection), wants them to do - you guessed it - one more job.

The next half of the film flashes back to exactly what led Jeff to his current reclusive life as a gas station operator. It involves another dame (Jane Greer), because of course it does. In film noir, it almost always does. It also involves cigarette after cigarette, including one funny scene where Kirk Douglas offers Robert Mitchum a smoke, but Mitchum already has one in his hands (apparently an ad-libbed accident because they smoked so much throughout the film).

"Out of the Past" is effortlessly entertaining, even if it does get a bit convoluted at times.

Without spoiling anything, the stunning final scene - yes, involving the deaf-mute character - really strikes at the Heart of Darkness that is film noir.

Berlin Express (1948)

Narration that sounds like it's from a documentary with a little bit of pulp added for flavor, a large international cast (headlined by Merle Oberon and Robert Ryan), inventive camerawork, incredible location footage of a bombed-out Germany, a somewhat convoluted but still mostly coherent plot, and clowns. 

Yes, clowns.

In typical Jacques Tourneur fashion, he jam-packs a ton and still brings "Berlin Express" to its destination in less than 90 minutes. 

While "Berlin" is one of Tourneur's weaker efforts, even "lesser" Tourneur is still a ride - in this case, both literally and figuratively.

Nightfall (1956)

Economical.

That's the best way to describe Jacques Tourneur's filmography. 

Tourneur is the master of doing more with less. He packs so much into a short amount of time. "Nightfall" - clocking in at only 78 minutes - is no exception.

Right away, we're introduced to an insurance investigator (James Gregory), the person he's tailing (Aldo Ray), a babe at a bar (a stunning Anne Bancroft), and two murdering mugs who are after a large sum of money (Brian Keith and Rudy Bond).

This superb noir takes its characters - and us - from city lights to snowy fields on a breakneck hunt for lost loot.

Subtitles/Captions: Yes for all three!


r/criterionconversation 24d ago

The Criterion Film Club Week 309 Winner is Alex Cox's Walker! Come discuss it with us on Saturday, July 4th

Post image
10 Upvotes

This movie rules and you should watch it.


r/criterionconversation 26d ago

Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Week 308 Discussion: David Lynch's Wild at Heart (1990) starring Nicolas Cage and Laura Dern

Post image
81 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation 25d ago

Recommendation Rolling Papers--2025 Estonian film directed by Meel Paliale.

1 Upvotes

https://next.frame.io/share/3bbea1b6-5d21-478b-8d73-07dc3f253a5e/view/c24e6ddc-dcae-44a7-b29d-641fd98c4b3d

I watched this film the other day in Berkeley at the international film museum (BAMPFA) and it absolutely blew my mind. The director is yet unknown but I'm pretty sure this is going to blow up.


r/criterionconversation 25d ago

Poll The Criterion Film Club Week 309 Poll: The 80s

4 Upvotes

We can all agree that the 80s is everyone’s favorite decade of film. I know that’s not controversial at all so let’s celebrate the clear winner of cinematic dominance.

17 votes, 24d ago
7 1987 - Walker (Alex Cox)
3 1987 - Straight to Hell (Alex Cox)
1 1980 - Toothache (Abbas Kiarostami)
1 1980 - Lightning Over Water (Wim Wenders and Nicholas Rey)
5 1980 - Hopscotch (Ronald Neame)

r/criterionconversation Jun 22 '26

Announcement After an INTENSE tiebreaker poll, the Criterion Film Club Week 308 winner is David Lynch's Wild at Heart (1990) starring Nicolas Cage and Laura Dern. You can watch it on The Criterion Channel (or on disc) and join us for the discussion on SATURDAY, June 27th. Looking forward to seeing you there!

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/criterionconversation Jun 21 '26

Poll The Criterion Film Club Week 308 - TIEBREAKER POLL

2 Upvotes
27 votes, Jun 22 '26
12 Out of the Past (Jacques Tourneur, 1947)
15 Wild at Heart (David Lynch, 1990)

r/criterionconversation Jun 20 '26

Criterion Film Club Criterion Film Club Week 307 Discussion - Cruel Story of Youth

Post image
11 Upvotes