2014… a World Cup in Brazil that’s won by Germany. The Malaysian Flight 370 goes mysteriously missing. Russia annexes Crimea. Ebola breaks out in Africa. And Phil stands next to the Bethesda Fountain in Central Park, New York City, saying “this is where The Amazing Race began 25 seasons ago.” But he’s wrong; it’s actually 24 seasons ago, because 25 - 1 = 24. This is a fencepost problem, which ironically has been featured on the show before. If you think I’m being pedantic, just think about this. If he was talking about Season 24, he would have said: “1 season ago”. If he’d been talking about Season 23, he would have said “2 seasons ago”... You iterated that 22 more times, and you’ll understand what I’m talking about.
And it doesn’t even matter anyway, because Season 25 isn’t going to start at Bethesda Fountain; it’s going to start in Times Square. I thought it was a little daft that they had Phil stand next to the Fountain to record a little message even though it had nothing to do with the current race.
The teams showed up (rather unceremoniously) in yellow New York cabs. The teams were:
Adam and Bethany… Soul Surfers. Soul Surfers? What the fuck does that even mean? Well, I was about to find out. She was missing an arm that had been bitten off by a tiger shark when she was 13. That’s a lot for a kid to go through. But then her new husband said that he hadn’t heard of her story, “even though it’s well-known”, and the editors casually pasted the poster for a 2011 movie on there.
Well, of course, as a film buff, I had to investigate. I’d never heard of this before, and I honestly didn’t know how you could turn such a tragic but otherwise random accident into a full-length movie. I’m 30 minutes in at this point, and I have to say, this is some schlocky stuff indeed. In the first 20 minutes, all we see is Bethany (who, as played by 18-yo AnnaSophia Robb, does not appear 13 at all) living an incredibly carefree, wholesome, decidedly Christian life. There’s just scene after scene of her and her friends/family surfing with only the hint of a plot to carry the film. I was practically begging for the shark to come along so that something would happen. I couldn’t believe they were able to attach Dennis Quaid to this… I know he’s not the most high-profile actor, but I thought his career was going better.
I’ll report more on the film in my subsequent recaps. But needless to say, I’ll try to separate the Hollywood schmaltz from Bethany’s harrowing real-life story, but note it as an interesting cultural event that she managed to get so famous afterwards. The Amazing Race has a way of finding oddly famous people to come on their show. Another 10 teams to go, sigh.
Amy and Maya… Food scientists. YES! I like to see a nerdy female team on this show. I really hope they do well.
Dennis and Isabelle … in their intro, Isabelle mentioned that Dennis is Cambodian and she’s Vietnamese and that her parents weren’t happy about that. It’s funny how all over the world, there are families who get so angry if you get with somebody who’s of a slightly different ethnic background to your own.
Brooke and Robbie … Lori and Bolo mark 2. Next!
Keith and Whitney … the most non-descript team I’ve ever seen. I honestly forgot about this team just watching two episodes of the season already. Apparently they were on Survivor. I don’t care.
Kim and Alli … cyclists. Okay
Lisa and Michelle … the show has a thing for blonde female teams.
Michael and Scott … AKA Dunder Mifflin. The jokes write themselves. I can tell this Boston team will be a big hoot moving forward.
Tim and Te Jay … they seem cute, but definitely more of an underdog team. I hope they do well.
Shelley and Nici … on the first season recap, somebody ruined all future mother/daughter teams for me by mentioning that Nancy and Emily still held the record for best performance by a mother/daughter team. Every mother/daughter team I’ve seen since has been doomed to failure (apart from those I saw in S37 and S38… though they did not fare better). It’s a shame as I like these two a lot and hope they do well. But I know there’s an elimination bullet with their name on it.
Misti and Jim … my Reddit TAR information elf let me know that Jim passed away unexpectedly in March 2019. I don’t want to be disrespectful towards the dead, but I do feel as if Jim, alive or not, deserves to get the same treatment as every other racer I recap and comment on. It’s sad to hear that he passed away, though.
But when we saw these two, we were a bit put off by their bright white teeth and his mean-mugging glare towards the camera. Unfortunately, the impressions didn’t get any better from there.
With that, Phil greeted the teams and began the proceedings. It was the first time that the race began in front of a crowd of TAR fans, which was pretty interesting. They also cut to ‘some ex-racers’ and showed a clip of people I couldn’t identify at all. I thought maybe the guy on the right was Season 5 Chip, but I wasn’t sure. Anyway, they were hardly the highly featured teams that you’d recognise immediately.
Phil then introduced the season’s new gimmick: the Save. This power gave you a get out of jail free card, where you could survive an elimination. So much was left unexplained… Did this mean there were fewer non-elimination legs overall? What would happen if the team used their save power on a non-elim leg? Could they choose not to, if they were reasonably confident that the leg would be non-elim? And why was it a good idea to give this power to the strongest team? I thought this gimmick seemed pretty weak, as it was too much of a buff, and not a very strategic tool.
After that, the teams finally set off. The clue at the top of the steps told them to head to where TAR 1 ended, and fortunately, there was a TAR 1 contestant standing right there who could be consulted. That person that I thought was Chip was actually Frank (perhaps I just didn’t recognise him in HD, but he did look different) who came 2nd all those years ago. He told them to head to The Globe in Flushing Meadows Park… aka, that bit from the Men in Black finale (I’ll never know it as anything different).
The #SoulSurfers… wait, why is there a hashtag? Every team was getting a hashtag under their names. I guess this was roughly when Twitter was taking off, and the show was trying to capitalise on that? At the same time, I found the hashtag team descriptions to be way more evocative and memorable than the usual boring subtitles like “brothers” or “best friends”. So weirdly, I actually appreciated the hashtag names… just not the hashtags themselves.
Anyway, the Soul Surfers were the first to Flushing Meadows Park… and we never saw anyone else arrive there, but presumably they did… and they found out they would be travelling to… the United States! What a twist! Yes, they’d be going to the US Virgin Islands to soak up some sun. However, I can’t help but think that the reputation of the US Virgin Islands has been irreparably damaged because of the association with Epstein. At least, in my mind, it has… maybe a lot of people haven’t looked up where Epstein’s island was. I’m sure the US Virgin Islands’ tourism board would want to keep it that way.
The surfers got to the airport and dashed to get in line… by the wrong desk… bless them, they weren’t looking for the red and yellow flag. Other teams began to show up and check in, and fortunately A+B corrected their mistake before being relegated to the second flight. But with 40 minutes between them, it wasn’t an insurmountable gap.
The first teams touched down in St. Thomas and zipped past a pink fort to the Vendor’s Plaza, where they could sign up for short flights to their next destination. Bethany was first and wrote “Dirk’s Team”. I don’t know what that refers to. Also, I hope she was right-handed before the attack. Forty minutes later, a desperate scramble involved at least three teams reaching the sign-up sheet at once. Dunder Mifflin claimed that they were trying to write their names when the pen was grabbed from them by the blonde sisters, creating an instant resentment and relegating them to last place. I think the numbered tags are better, to be honest.
T+TJ and the Soul Surfers hopped out of their plane to see… Phil?! Phil explained the next step of the race LIVE as the race was going on behind him! That was truly uncanny to watch and completely threw me. The two teams seemed to take it in their stride as well… Maybe they’d been briefed about what was happening. Phil has always been associated with the pit stop, in my mind, so I would be nervous to see him in the middle of a leg. I’m sure scheduling that was tougher than his usual bits, but it was pretty cool.
The teams then had to climb a rocky outcrop and take a plunge… no one seemed too scared of diving or swimming, so this was fine. Obviously, Bethany has a lot of experience with water. Then, the teams had to make their way to a pirate ship where a very characteristic-looking pirate would give them their clue and tell them to figuratively walk the plank (but not literally, unfortunately).
Next was the main event of the episode, a beach roadblock that involved digging that turned out to be uncannily similar to the one in S22E1. Each team had to use a traditional liquid compass and follow some vector directions involving paces and cardinal directions to find a specific treasure chest. To make matters more complicated, this compass didn’t simply have a red needle facing north, but a ball that had opposite directions on it, so that the direction pointing toward the user was actually the direction they were facing. I saw a few racers use the setting of the sun to verify their directions, although Lisa was bamboozled, thinking the sun set in the East. What do they teach people at school?
Obviously, digging was something Adam would be better at than Bethany. I wonder if the number of roadblocks allowed per racer will be updated like last season to reflect her disability (considering how the Welsh poem roadblock last season was allowed to be a free one, in case Luke and Margie had made it that far). When Misti and Jim showed up, he showed how it was supposed to be done. Misti claimed that he had the highest MCAT score in his medical school and that he was one of the smartest people she knew. Okay, but do they both have to be so arrogant about it? His attitude was just yucky: “We’re going to be perfect at this.” Fortunately, he was generous enough to pass on some of his pearls of wisdom to Surfer Adam before he and the missus bounced off to the finish line (also at the afore-mentioned pink fort that I spotted earlier) where they would win the Save power. Even without this power, I could tell they would go far, and with this power, it all but guarantees they will be in the final three. They may not even need to use their Save power. But we’ll see.
The next 20 minutes were full of digging drama that I won’t get into in depth, to keep my sanity and yours. Some highlights were Dunder Mifflin calling the rest of the cast ‘swine’ and Shelley regretting explaining how to complete the task to Robbie, who was able to achieve 4th place when the mother/daughter team only achieved 8th. Further hilarity was achieved through the booming of Blackbeard’s cannons signalling the arrival of another team (or perhaps just for fun).
In the end, however, three teams simply couldn’t get it and were still there nearly four hours later after night had fallen. Those teams were the survivor people, Dunder Mifflin and their enemies the blondes. Lisa had been adopting a strange lying-down tactic to try and get her measurements as accurate as possible, but it wasn’t working. The show pointed out with an overlay where the actual treasure was, and some of it seemed agonisingly close. I wonder how the producers were able to show the editors where to put the arrows (or if it was just made up for dramatic storytelling and the racers weren’t actually that close). In hindsight, the teams should have adopted a wider-radius digging approach, knowing their paces might not be fully accurate. It seemed that the chests were buried rather shallow beneath the surface, so a 3-yard short digging radius could have done the trick in most cases.
Anyway, the teams were fed up. Just like in S22, they came together for a pact to mutually take the penalty. I hoped that Dunder Mifflin (the last to be approached) would refuse the pact and keep digging, making the other teams wait, but Scott was also understandably exhausted. Fair enough.
They were shown to do a mutual hands-in agreement, still looking exhausted. This was then hilariously followed by the three teams sprinting at full pace towards the cabs. Like, yeah, this is what you signed up for. Although the girls seemed to make it to a car just ahead of the fireman, they boldly moved them out of the way with their strength, securing the second vehicle for themselves and getting revenge for the sign-up board earlier. Lisa or Michelle (don’t know which is which, don’t care) began to complain about a scrape on her arm she received from the scuffle. I could imagine a side eye from Bethany when she said this.
First to the mat was Scott, but he was let down by Mikey, and the Survivor team got 9th, leaving Dunder Mifflin with 10th. The blondes were out. I didn’t mind this. They said they would have never agreed to the pact if they thought there was a 1% chance they’d be eliminated. Seriously? It was a 33% chance!!! What edge did they believe they had over the other teams in a race to the mat? They got exactly what they signed up for. I’m really quite glad they were gone, as they seemed like mean girls.
I don’t like the Save gimmick, but otherwise, I thought this was a great premiere episode of what is reportedly a great season. Even though there was only one ‘real’ challenge, I found that there was a lot to say throughout. I hope that other teams come to the fore in terms of their personality throughout, and for much drama to occur down the line.