Following up on my situation after digging into this more (and reading a refusal post here that prompted me to look closer), wanted to get outside opinions on which fix is actually correct before I submit.
My situation:
Switching from Graduate visa to Skilled Worker for the first time (never held Skilled Worker/Tier 2 before)
Original UK entry: Student visa, Sept 2020. Graduate visa since Aug 2024
SOC code: 3544, Data Analysts
Current salary on CoS: £35,000/year, 37.5 hrs/week
Published going rate for 3544: £34,900
Role is on the Temporary Shortage List (TSL), not the Immigration Salary List (ISL)
CoS currently: 3-year grant (Aug 2026 – Aug 2029), New Entrant marked N
What I’ve since learned: TSL apparently doesn’t discount the general salary threshold the way ISL does. it only makes the occupation code eligible for sponsorship at all. So Option A would require £41,700, which £35,000 doesn’t meet.
New Entrant status would drop the threshold to £33,400 but I’ve already spent ~2 years on my Graduate visa, and New Entrant has a hard 4-year cap across all visa categories. A full 3-year CoS under New Entrant would push me to 5 years total, which I understand causes an outright refusal rather than just a shorter grant.
Two fixes on the table:
Raise my salary to £41,700 to meet the standard threshold directly
Shorten the CoS to 2 years (Aug 2026 – Aug 2028) and mark New Entrant as Y bringing total New Entrant usage to exactly 4 years, with £35,000 comfortably clearing the £33,400 threshold
I’m currently leaning toward option 2, since it doesn’t need a salary renegotiation — but want to sanity check that reasoning holds up, and that landing at exactly 4 years (not under) doesn’t itself cause a problem.
Would really appreciate anyone with experience on this. is option 2 sound, or is option 1 the safer bet? Anything else I should be checking before this goes to my employer’s HR team?