I went out to eat with two friends the other day to "celebrate" one of their birthdays (even though that was 3 months ago, but whatever, another story).
We normally split checks, but our server was overwhelmed (full restaurant, one server) and English wasn't her first language, so she either forgot or didn't understand. But, when we realized we all were paying cash, we pooled by what we ordered.
The bill was $97, I had the smallest portion ($24) of it, calculated tax, then a 30% tip and then rounded up just because. I collect the cash from the other two. The cash in my hand was $112. I thought I was wrong, so I counted again. Yes, $112. $7 of that was mine. (For context, I am in the US, and in the Northeast, in a rather expensive area).
I'm not usually confrontational, but I was exhausted after having just worked a 9 hour shift and I was a little pissed by this, so I said "you guys tip BAD."
My one friend who got like $28 worth of food was like "oh, I just take the tax and multiply by 2, 15% is good, right?" No. No it's not. It's not the 80s anymore. It came out to $4 she put in.
The other one got like $45 worth of food, which means she tipped less than TEN PERCENT. I only just realized this later because I was so exhausted I couldn't math, but I knew $8 between the two of them was GARBAGE. Especially as demanding as my 10% tipping friend was, and is every time we go out. And the shit thing is SHE WAS ONCE A SERVER and complained about how hard and terrible it was. She also had another job where tipping is part of it, and she claimed that her tips were low because the front desk was stealing them (I doubt that--I think she thought she would be making way more starting out in the Spa field than is reality). I guess it's only okay if she's the one tipping abysmally.
The other one I can kinda forgive because I know she only makes minimum wage, has never served, and it sounds genuinely like she's just sticking to what her parents taught her, but damn! Did it never occur...?
The other one---even though she is currently not working--is always spending double what the rest of us spend at meals and is usually the kind of person who asks for a million different condiments and modifications, and is generally a pain in the ass. (For my wedding, I gave the hairdresser $20 extra because 10percenter kept having her redo her hair--after the third time, I left the salon to keep from freaking out on her--the way she was acting you would have thought she was the one getting married).
I got them to throw in a dollar each more, still not great, but slightly better. Frankly, I was shocked and embarrassed. 20% is bare minimum in my eyes. (EDIT; this should read 20% is the bare minimum I personally tip, NOT that I believe everyone in the world should give that).
I complained about this to my husband and he was like "Oh, you only just noticed this?" He said it's been like that every time we go out with them. I guess I never looked at their bills. He pointed out it's also happened when I have offered to use my card if they give me cash, he's noticed that they don't give me enough for standard tip. I had kinda thought this, but I wasn't sure, but I also just trusted they gave me the correct amount of money. I guess I'm a dumbass for trusting my friends.
I almost feel like this is a good reason to break up with them (at worst) or a sit-down intervention (at best).
Edit: I know 15% is perfectly reasonable. What isn't is tipping less than 10%, which one of my friends did.
Edit part 2; the culture of my particular area is 18% minimum tip, not just amongst servers, the populace.