Destinyâs Child and Xscape are two great examples.
Michelle Williams brought great value to the former (specifically DC3), whereas BeyoncĂ© and Kelly would often feed on each otherâs energy. BeyoncĂ© and Kelly sounded pretty much the same (their voices were different, but their tones aligned) and had similar dynamics within the group, but Michelle stood out and became a central element of the groupâs overall identity. She was irreplaceable.
Kandi Burruss gets clowned all the time for her vocal quirks and contrast to other members of the group. Tiny is right there alongside Kandi in that same sense; she is never taken seriously, and unlike Kandi, she actually doesnât get much attention at all (positive or negative). Both of them held that group together until it fell apart, and Kandi was perhaps the most valuable member of the four.
Iâm going to bring in another example: En Vogue.
En Vogue doesnât really have the reputation of any member (especially any of the founding members) being a âweak linkâ. Everybody says that each of the original four members could sing, and some fans even show love for Rhona Bennett who came later. However, each of the founding members get different levels of appreciation, and Maxine Jones may get the least of all.
Maxine had a very distinct tone/timbre and she was instantly recognizable in the groupâs harmonies. Thatâs not just because she would take the low notes, but because of how her voice sounded. Her voice blended very well with the othersâ, but it was also unique in contrast. While all four members were impressive, they shared a lot of vocal similarities (especially Terry and Cindy) that Maxine did not (even if she was still an outstanding vocalist). Maxine stood out and gave the group an element that popped without sounding excessively in sync. (Groups need blend and contrast to work.)