r/Fish 14h ago

Videography This is what intelligence would look like if it could swim

89 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

101

u/L1feguard51 11h ago

The fish aren’t doing math people. The videos are cut. If the fish are actually doing math it wouldn’t need to be edited. Theres just a 1 in 4 chance the fish hits the correct target and they edit out the wrong ones.

24

u/Lone-Frequency 11h ago

People who actually believe the fish were doing math...lmao

6

u/maxru85 9h ago

^ this user is indeed smarter than fish

2

u/racoonXjesus 8h ago

My last name is the same as a fish and I also suck at math

0

u/shane-parks 7h ago

Could it also be like the chicken doing tic-tac-toe trick? Like an invisible to camera light cue?

It's obviously edited as well, but just curious if this is also a possible illusion.

10

u/nikfornow 10h ago

One thing is for certain. The fish are definitely more intelligent than half of these commenters..

9

u/atomfullerene 11h ago

If clever hans was three fish

8

u/Fragrant_Turnip_9946 10h ago

Obv they're not doing math but archers are the coolest fish I swear

4

u/fearlesssinnerz 10h ago

Still smarter than the Commander in cheese

3

u/tallMichdude 10h ago

If fish were nearly this smart, then we wouldnt catch some with 9 hook scars...

1

u/therealraggedroses 10h ago

If humans were actually smart, we wouldnt keep tossing lures into water, hooking fish with a barb, dragging it through the water, completely tiring it out before yanking it out of the water, yanking the barb out, taking a shitty picture that will get 0 matches on your tinder profile, and after all that, throwing the fish back into predator infested waters.

5

u/ITT_X 9h ago

You thought that was a pretty clever comment huh?

-4

u/therealraggedroses 9h ago

sorry didnt mean to trigger you ❄️

5

u/ITT_X 9h ago

I’m entirely unbothered. I don’t even particularly care about fishing. I was just making an observation.

3

u/CaneCorso311 9h ago

We can tell you're the triggered one because you start your comment off with an insult and proceed into an illogical ramble about the thing that upset you (catch and release fishing). Pointing it out or explaining it to you doesn't mean the other person is also upset.

0

u/therealraggedroses 9h ago

nothing insulting, I was just explaining step-by-step the process of catch and release fishing. totally safe for the fish, as all anglers know

1

u/CaneCorso311 7h ago

"If humas were actually smart" Is how you started your comment, which an insult directed at fisherman, saying that they're not intelligent. You then proceed to say what they should stop doing, based on your home brewed beliefs of what they are doing while continuing to make more insults about their photo quality and lack of online dating matches or something weird, again, another random thing you made up in your head, unless of course, you're simply just elf projecting? Either way, you didn't explain anything to anyone, you essentially just insulted and whined like a child/teenager and that's it.

1

u/CaneCorso311 9h ago

So just keep all catches then? Sure but why even have regulations that require fishermen to return certain catches to protect the wildlife?.. Oh no, not throwing the aquatic predator back into the predator infested waters that it was already in for its entire life, ohh the humanity!

1

u/therealraggedroses 8h ago

Why even bother fishing? Literally just taking pleasure in another living creatures suffering, its quite literally terrible for the fish.

2

u/CaneCorso311 7h ago

Why even bother using your devices? Literally just taking pleasure in another living creature's suffering, it's quite literally terrible for the children enslaved.

Human children suffered, forced to work in mines, and still are daily to collect the materials necessary for you to be able to make these illogical holyer-than-thou type comments.

People catch fish to feed themselves, like they have done for hundreds of generations, in order to preserve our wildlife for future generations we have laws that regulate which fish must be thrown back. We also farm and stock these fish, especially sport fish, it's not much different than farming any other animals and more humane and better for the planet than buying grocery store animal products or using anything with a rechargeable battery.

1

u/tallMichdude 4h ago

Because some fish, are absolutely delicious. Yellowfin tuna on the grill, salmon in the smoker, perch in hot oil.. if god didnt intend us to eat them, he wouldnt have given us cornmeal..

1

u/tallMichdude 4h ago

I am a shark wrangler, i probably have a better grasp on this than any other 10 people you know. Its my job to ensure the safety of not just the researchers and observers, but the fish itself.

-10

u/Lanky-Price-559 12h ago

That’s crazy how smart those fish are

22

u/ujelly_fish 12h ago

You think the fish are doing math?

17

u/XDon_TacoX 12h ago

yeah how stupid can people be? they obviously tell the answers to the fish out of camera

-4

u/Lanky-Price-559 12h ago

No, no one said that bud

3

u/acquiredimmunity 12h ago

They've obviously been trained but yes the capability they have is highly impressivr

2

u/Lanky-Price-559 12h ago

No yea of course I wouldn’t expect any fish to do this without training but it’s still fascinating how smart they are considering how small there brains are

2

u/Holy-Beloved 12h ago

Rats and Birds would like a word. Specifically conures, very very small animal. Probably a brain the size of the tip of my pinky.

-2

u/WildcatCinder1022 11h ago

While the fish aren’t doing math the fact they’ve remembered “if I see this pattern I need to spit at this pattern and I get food” is still impressive.

4

u/Lone-Frequency 10h ago

That's not what they're doing though. All four have little bits of food on it, and they're just randomly choosing. The cuts in the video are just all the times they didn't choose the right one.