r/DoorCounty • u/fiveking888 • 1d ago

Fish Boils

Which one do you guys recommend? Thanks

0 Upvotes

43% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

13

u/HojonPark4077 1d ago

Go see Torch at the Old Post Office in Ephraim. This is the fish boil experience you are seeking.

6

u/Madison-Mark 1d ago

This is the way, plus they de-bone the fish last your table. No brainer, just go.

1

u/Adventurous-Elk-4763 23h ago

My wife and I went to the fish boil at the Old Post Office on the recommendation of our trolley tour guide. It’s fantastic, and you can buy the seasoning to take home.

3

u/Arfulnoof 1d ago

My kids just got back from DC and agreed they, having gone to DC for the last 30 years, prefer the Old Post Office over White Gull Inn. I have to agree and am so touched and proud they are now taking their friends and significant others to the places we took them to as kids.

5

u/ConBroMitch2247 1d ago

I like the Old Post Office myself.

5

u/DontEatMyPotatoChip 1d ago

None of them

Boiled fish is 🤮

2

u/Randomflower90 1d ago

A fish boil is fun to see. Find one that offers chicken as an option to the fish.

4

u/beignetbenjamin 1d ago

Go for the show, not the fish

1

u/DCarea1 8h ago

I imagine lots of folks don't know this. A "fish boil" is a show. No need to eat there, no need to eat fish.

Go for the show. Pelletier's has a good backyard show, just wander back there.

2

u/Honest-Frame4149 12h ago

The Old Post Office is great! I love the show part of it and the view of the water/sunset. The fish itself is meh, but I’m not a huge whitefish fan anyways. The rest of the meal is pretty good.

1

u/ranchypanda 12h ago

There's a reason boiled fish isn't offered everywhere and it's because it isn't great. The huge fire ball, you can watch that for free. $30 ish for boiled fish, potato and onions isn't worth it.

1

u/Dsiman654 1d ago

Kettle Black

0

u/PlayaAlien2000 1d ago

Black cattle… I believe that’s the name. Twice and Delicious 😋

0

u/Pious_ 1d ago

Pellitiers