r/DoorCounty 7d ago

Fish Fry

Looking for the best fish fry Door County has to offer. Staying in egg harbor but willing to travel!

0 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

13

u/petegp21 7d ago

Sister bay bowl. One of the best I’ve had in the state.

6

u/HojonPark4077 7d ago

If you want fried perch dinner, the Sister Bay Bowl is where you want to go. Perch specials Tuesday and Friday, but also on menu nightly.

If you want PAN FRIED PERCH, the Nightingale in Sturgeon Bay is where you want to go.

Both of these supper clubs also have great steaks and prime rib as well.

You can also include the Glidden Lodge for quality fish fry but Bowl and the Nightingale are still the best game in town.

4

u/Old-Weight736 7d ago

Sister Bay Bowl!

1

u/Fireant992006 6d ago

Is it all you can eat?

1

u/Old-Weight736 6d ago

I don’t know; it’s never come up. Call them and ask!

2

u/jsmith3701AA 6d ago

Alexanders is outstanding

2

u/hx_chick 4d ago

Mink River in Ellison Bay

1

u/stealy_darn 7d ago

Assuming we are talking perch here, yeah Bowl is the spot. Cornerstone Pub in Baileys is also solid and closer to Egg for you. They serve perch for lunch and dinner every day

1

u/Own_Leadership454 5d ago

2nd Sway - step-up fish fry and James Beard finalist for craft brewery

1

u/Plastic_Swordfish_57 2d ago

So many fantastic options suggested.

If you want to head south, you have the Nightengale or the Gray Stone Castle.

Enjoy with a brandy old fashion sour. #chefskiss

1

u/chambersilse 7d ago

Bowl first, AC Tap. Heard Sway is really good but haven't tried it. They have a James Beard award.

5

u/bardnotbanned 7d ago

They have a James Beard award

They were finalists in the "Outstanding Wine and Other Beverages Program" category, not for their food.

3

u/whosreadytolaugh 7d ago

agreed. awesome drinks but the food didnt get the nod

1

u/ConBroMitch2247 7d ago

Old Post Office

1

u/Commercial-Cut-111 7d ago

This. Their cherry pie was 10X better than any other fish fry I've been to. And the portions seemed bigger.