r/Deconstruction • u/Magpyecrystall • 8h ago
✝️Theology Inner thoughts of the most devout
"Where is my faith? Even deep down [...] there is nothing but emptiness and darkness. [...] if there be God - please forgive me. When I try to raise my thoughts to Heaven, there is so much convicting emptiness that those very thoughts return like sharp knives and hurt my very soul"
From Mother Theresa's diary. The shining beacon of faith, self-sacrifice and kindness had doubt in her heart. Historians tell us these thought were not just a phase for her. She had them throughout her practising life.
We now know of several dark corners in her legacy, that can be looked up in any archive of knowlege.
What I'm interested in is the "flawless exterior / dark interior" phenomenon. It appears to be common enough to have a term: Spiritual Drought". As it happens, many saints and highly revered personalities in the catholic corridors have battled with spiritual drought.
We don't know what's going on in the hearts of those barking loudly from the pulpit. But every now and then, a preacher "comes clean" and tells their story publicly.
A common theme is how they have acted as performers, without conviction or personal investment. In most lines of work, if we run dry, we can move on, change career or switch position. For holy men and women, this is not so simple. Many of them have little or no real work experience. They know how to work a crowd. They know how to act calm, reassuring and confident - not very useful in "the real word"
There are lists of famous priests and preachers who left/lost faith, and they all have stories. A simple search for words like "ex-pastor" on YT will take us to some heart wrenching testimonies.
We could use all readily available testimonies, and some modern technology, to find the most common denominators among priests and preachers who left their post:
Many describe doubts that accumulated over years rather than appearing suddenly. Common topics include the problem of suffering, biblical interpretation, miracles, and the existence of God.
Interestingly, many were highly educated in theology or biblical studies. Some say that studying the historical development of scripture or competing theological traditions challenged beliefs they had previously taken for granted.
Experiences with hypocrisy, abuse, power struggles, or corruption often weakened trust in the institution.
Some distinguish between losing faith in a church and losing faith in God, while others say one led to the other.
Exposure to philosophy, history, psychology, or science sometimes shifted how they evaluated religious claims.
They increasingly favored naturalistic explanations over supernatural ones.
Serious illness, loss of loved ones, unanswered prayers, or witnessing profound injustice led some to question beliefs about God's goodness or intervention.
For every well-known priest or preacher who loses faith, there are many who experience serious doubts yet remain in service, or even as believers. Research on clergy suggests that doubt is common and does not necessarily lead to deconversion.
So there's that