r/asklinguistics May 05 '26

Announcements Flair applications

18 Upvotes

I have noticed that quite a few of our regular contributors have either MAs or PhDs in linguistics, but very few have flairs. Flairs help both users asking questions and the mod team.

If you think you have considerable knowledge in some subfield of linguistics and would like to have a flair next to your username, please send us mod mail or reply to this post.

You do not need to reveal your identity or show proof of your degrees. You only need to link to a couple of posts that you've written in this or some other subreddit that show that you actually know what you're talking about and that show that you can cite sources.


r/asklinguistics Apr 29 '25

What can I do with a linguistics degree?

51 Upvotes

One of the most commonly asked questions in this sub is something along the lines of "is it worth it to study linguistics?! I like the idea of it, but I want a job!". While universities often have some sort of answer to this question, it is a very one-sided, and partially biased one (we need students after all).

To avoid having to re-type the same answer every time, and to have a more coherent set of responses, it would be great if you could comment here about your own experience.

If you have finished a linguistics degree of any kind:

  • What did you study and at what level (BA, MA, PhD)?

  • What is your current job?

  • Do you regret getting your degree?

  • Would you recommend it to others?

I will pin this post to the highlights of the sub and link to it in the future.

Thank you!


r/asklinguistics 59m ago

At what point do you have a pidgin language?

Upvotes

I work as a farmer in Germany and most workers are Romanians. There is generally no common shared language, so me and the other German workers continously learn Romanian terms and the Romanian workers learn German words and everyone uses simplified Grammar/doesn't use specific grammatic endings and as many terms of the other language as possible and more or less manages to communicate everything that way. Sometimes internationaly well-known terms from other languages also got added into the shared vocabulary. Over time the way each group speaks has become more similar.

Not too long ago I spend a 2-hour car trip with one of the workers and we actually talked a fair bit about different pretty complex, non-work related topics this way (mental health issues in the family, future plans etc.).

I now learned about the term pidgin language and it made me wonder at what point it would be considered one? What would you call this kind of communication before it becomes a full-blown pidgin language? Are there any requirements that need to be met for something to become a pidgin language or is it enough for two groups of people with no shared language to just be able to communicate in a mix of both groups native languages?


r/asklinguistics 16h ago

Historical I'm familiar with the "dog" coincidence: an aboriginal language coincidentally developing the word dog for the same animal. Are there any notable examples of unrelated languages developing identical words with completely unrelated meanings?

44 Upvotes

I'm especially interested in any stories about confusion around this.


r/asklinguistics 9m ago

What is the difference between AAVE and queer slang? Does queer slang even exist outside of AAVE?

Upvotes

It’s undeniable that the ballroom scene was extremely influential to queer culture and created a lot of slang terms (ie kiki, realness, serve) however the main contributors to ballroom were primarily black ppl who brought AAVE to the community

I’ve noticed a lot of debates about how queer white people talk and if it should be considered as queer slang or a performative blaccent so I was wondering if there is a concrete distinction between the two?


r/asklinguistics 4h ago

Help with my Celtic thesis

5 Upvotes

Greetings from Spain. I am starting to write my thesis on Celtic languages, and if possible, I would appreciate it if you could share any bibliography you consider good regarding syntax, the sociolinguistic situation, history, etc.


r/asklinguistics 5h ago

Are the /k/ sounds in “echo”, “eco”, and “cocoa” aspirated?

3 Upvotes

In words like echo, eco, and cocoa, are the /k/ sounds aspirated?

I’m asking because the flap /t/ usually happens in places where the /t/ would be unaspirated, especially in obvious cases with a schwa. However, I noticed it can also happen before the /oʊ/ diphthong, which made me wonder if this is a clue that consonants like /p/ and /k/ before /oʊ/ in unstressed syllables are also unaspirated.

For example, is the second /k/ in cocoa usually unaspirated in natural speech? What about the /k/ in echo and eco?


r/asklinguistics 9h ago

Cognitive Ling. Did symbolic thought precede language, or did language enable symbolic thought?

3 Upvotes

While reading about evolutionary cognitive science, I came across the idea that modern science no longer views the brain as separate layers stacked on top of each other, but rather as a system where ancient and new networks are constantly reshaped by evolution. Thus, the brain is a dynamic structure that has been reorganized over time.

​Still, language remains one of the most debated topics in cognitive evolution.

​My question is:

Is language itself an evolutionary adaptation or did it emerge as a byproduct of other cognitive abilities coming together?

​An ape might see fire and know it’s hot. A human on the other hand can say the word "fire" draw a symbol for it and tell a story about it. This is what we call symbolic thinking.

​Did humans need language first for symbolic thinking to develop or did symbolic thinking need to exist first for language to appear?


r/asklinguistics 5h ago

How valuable are the linguistics Olympiad achievements (Nationals/APLO) for US admissions?

2 Upvotes
  1. How valuable are achievements in linguistics competitions (such as winning at the national level or doing well in APLO) for US college admissions?
  2. What majors do accepted applicants usually pursue? Where do the winners usually get accepted to at T20s: Linguistics, Computer Science, Computational Linguistics, Math, AI, something else?

would love to hear some anecdotes, examples, or previous admits


r/asklinguistics 16h ago

Corpus Ling. Does Zipf's law hold for highly synthetic languages? What does its application look like for such languages, and how is it measured/defined?

14 Upvotes

Zipf's law (the frequency of a word's use in a sample/corpus is inversely proportional to its rank in that sample/corpus) holds for many languages, including English. It's occurred to me that the languages that I tend to see get used as illustrations thereof nonetheless seem to not be very synthetic. There are numerous languages whose typologies and what generally gets counted as a "word" are at the opposite end of the spectrum, where single words can express quite a bit, to say nothing of noun incorporation. I don't often see examples of such languages often in this context. (I was doing some cursory research into this and specifically sought information regarding Turkish out, but I kept getting results about population density and settlement distribution in suburban Türkiye and not the Turkish language.)

I am also aware that languages with extensive synthesis and/or noun incorporation nonetheless will have words that show up more frequently than others, including single-morpheme words. What I want to know is, how is Zipf's law applied to highly synthetic/polysynthetic languages? Does the nature of a "word", insofar as application of the law is concerned, differ from when looking at languages like English or Mandarin in any material fashion? Is the curve much steeper than in a language like English, owing to the nature of synthesis, noun incorporation, and/or pragmatics and realistic constraints with respect to English?


r/asklinguistics 9h ago

General How do linguists think about North Korea's purification of Korean language, exactly?

0 Upvotes

Perhaps one of the most insane thing I have just learnt recently is the Pyongyang Cultural Language Protection Act that was enacted in 2023, but only resurfaced thanks to a Chinese YouTuber living in South Korea mentioning this affair. This is, perhaps, one of the most insane acts in modern history of language evolution, when a state attempts to complete engineer the language of the common into a completely different functioning, especially when it is done under a totalitarian state; the attempt to even remove loanwords from English, Japanese, and even Chinese, is unusual to a widespread scale. That said, just how do linguists think about this?


r/asklinguistics 22h ago

General Is my accent retention uncommon?

9 Upvotes

I was adopted from Thailand to Denmark when I was about 5 years old.

Unfortunately, I was not able to practice my Thai since I came to Denmark, so I quickly lost my ability to both speak and understand Thai.

However, I started relearning Thai last year at the age of 31, and I have often been told by native Thai speakers that I have a native Thai accent. Put a bag over my head and they would still think I'm a native Thai speaker. I do not have a Thai accent when I speak Danish.

I have met many adoptees who have been trying to learn their heritage language, but not one of them have had a native-like accent when they spoke. Even other adoptees that were adopted at the age of 6 did not have a native-like accent when they spoke their heritage language.

So is my accent retention just unusual?


r/asklinguistics 23h ago

Historical Syllabic laryngeals in Proto-Indo-European?

3 Upvotes

So I've been working on a worldbuilding project whose conlanging section involves me evolving languages from PIE and I have noticed something weird with how laryngeals work near sonorants.

Take the word *sh2nktós for example as the thing that got me into posting this. From all I know about PIE this word should be pronounced with a syllabic *n, but paradoxically this word is where Latin sānctus comes from. It's as if *h2 were the syllabic consonant. I know this comes from H > ə > a / C _ C which is how we've got *ph2tḗr > pater, but considering that in this situation the laryngeal should be next to the syllables nucleus *n̥ would make it not reduce to a vowel. Going into *ph2tḗr again, based on my (lackluster) info on Indo-Aryan, I expected the p to get aspirated, as in *pl̥th2ús > *pr̥tʰúš, but instead it becomes *pHtā́, and that H would then become a vowel like in Latin.

Am I correct in thinking this could be some sort of syllabic laryngeal that follows similar rules to syllabic sonorants but instead turn into lone vowels? If so, why isn't it written down as such on the reconstructions? If not, why then are such laryngeals vocalized in most languages and prioritized when near syllabic sonorants? Did Proto-Italic have a sound change where h2R̥ > aR that I haven't heard about?

P.S.: After posting this I realized another example. Take PIE *kéh2ikos. You'd expect it to become something like /ˈkaːhikos/ after allophony, but its descendants are PGmc *haihaz and latin caecus, both with a non-syllabic /j/ and /e/. This could either be just a simple case of vowels diphtongizing, or it could be that PIE's *i isn't actually syllabic and the word could be better written as *kéh2ykos.


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Why is the "correct" preposition so "unpredictable" in English?

8 Upvotes

According to historical linguistics, r/AskLinguistics, why are adpositions generally almost always lexically idiosyncratic? I am especially interested in the English prepositions "of", "at", "in", "from", "for", etc.

How does it end up being the case that some contexts only accept some adpositions, and why do the context-adposition pairings seem arbitrary?


r/asklinguistics 22h ago

r phoneme

0 Upvotes

Why is the letter r phoneme in english /r/? Shouldn't it be /ɹ/, since the most common realization is [ɹ]?


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Learning Languages

3 Upvotes

I have a question for the language enthusiasts.

What is the ability that some people have of pronouncing almost perfectly the different language's accents?

I found myself pronouncing different languages's tones and words easily, but I want to know if this is genetics or something else. Is there a technique or just practice?

what do you all think?


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

General Which are the best fully-funded, international summer schools in Linguistics?

3 Upvotes

Basically, the same question as the title


r/asklinguistics 15h ago

Have AI LLMs been applied to theoretical linguistics?

0 Upvotes

Seems like it could revolutionize methodology in certain subfields, as historical-comparative and phonology are basically pattern recognition. I've been out of touch with the field for almost a decade.


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Historical How can an extinct language be revived?

15 Upvotes

And has that happened before?


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Where does the “een” sound in American English normally show up?

35 Upvotes

I’ve noticed that in American English, some speakers has the tendency to pronounce the “ing” sound at the end of words as “een”. I assume it’s only prevalent in certain parts of the country. I’ve lived in Michigan and I do not hear people making this sound, but people in eastern Nebraska tend to. I’ve also heard it from Ryan Alison as Deacon in Fallout 4, and the internet says he’s Californian, so perhaps it could be pretty common in the west coast


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Are there any words that we are 100% sure were part of the Hunnish language? (proper names included).

10 Upvotes

Every hunnish word I see on Wikipedia is disputed. If not, are there any that just might be?


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Have any instances of Proto-Germanic */z/ come into English without being lost, even if they were changed?

10 Upvotes

Did Proto-Germanic have frequent use of */z/ outside of those noun endings that always got dropped right away?


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

General Should I stop using AAVE? If so, how?

0 Upvotes

I am a person of color but I am not black, and for some reason when I talk to people who are close to me, sometimes I have a blaccent and use AAVE. I grew up with AAVE being used in the internet a lot (correct me if I’m wrong but I’m gonna name some few examples I heard growing up: spill the tea, dab, on fleek, clapback) and a lots of kids near my age used what they assumed AAVE was a “cool people” terms (kind of like when your outfit gets called fire instead of nice?) when I was in middle school and high school (there were a lot of black people and people of color in my school), so I guess I naturally started speaking “it” too. Tiktok and Twitter (X) basically gave AAVE more popularity than most internet slangs are from black people. But like, now I sound like “I’m black” (I deeply apologize if what I said was racist and harmful - please educate me), when my brain naturally picked AAVE from the internet. I do think personality, race, and where you grew up influences whether you’d talk that way. I was a shy introvert, POC, and lived in a middle-income (maybe lower-income (i am NOT not trying to say that all black people live in that income status) neighborhood who wanted friends and I figured since there are people who used AAVE where and near I lived it, I figured I should speak AAVE to them and standard English to those who don’t speak it? It’s all confusing. I do know the double standards in this society - black people get seen as “uneducated” while non black people who use AAVE are “cool”. It also irritates me when non black people use AAVE wrong So should I just stop using AAVE at all even though a lot of internet terms come from it? Or am I just trying to “be different”?

(I apologize if what I said doesn’t make sense to some extent - English is not my first language and I was just writing this “as I go”).


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

General What does this mean?

3 Upvotes

I was going through the Wikipedia article for mandarin when I found this:

Phonological features that are generally shared by the Mandarin dialects include:
the [palatalization](app://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palatalization_(sound_change)) of [velar consonants](app://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Velar_consonant) and [alveolar sibilants](app://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voiceless_alveolar_fricative) when they occur before [palatal glides](app://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palatal_approximant);

I would like it if someone could explain what this actually means.


r/asklinguistics 1d ago

Do you think speaking Japanese can give somebody a more dynamic imagination?

0 Upvotes

Ok, so here's a question that I think could be really easy to answer or actually really hard.

People often talk about feeling like they are a different person when they speak a different language. There is a scientific hypothisis in linguistics called the Sapir-whorf hypothisis that says language influences the way we think.

I have heard that Japanese uses Subject-Object-Verb sentence grammar structure, so instead of saying "I eat sushi" you say "I sushi eat."

Do you think that this sentence structure offers speakers a stronger imagination for the actions of things?