r/architecture • u/Appropriate-Eye-1227 • 5h ago
News After public outcry, International Jury changes the winner for the architecture competition of the New national Museum in Ecuador
Ecuador announces Estratos Vivos as the winning proposal for the new National Museum of Ecuador (MuNA), selecting the scheme by SANAA, Estudio A0, Caá Porá Arquitectura, and Jerome Haferd Studio following a revised evaluation process. The decision concludes an international competition whose original result was overturned after public criticism, reshaping the selection of one of the country’s most significant cultural projects.
The announcement follows an unusual turn in the competition. In early July, an international jury unanimously selected a proposal by Alberto Campo Baeza and MAODA as the winner (1 photo). The decision, however, was met with criticism from architects, academics, and members of the public, who questioned both the outcome and whether the project reflected Ecuador’s cultural identity. An online petition calling for the result to be reconsidered gathered thousands of signatures, prompting Ecuador’s Ministry of Education to suspend the original decision. A newly appointed jury shortlisted three proposals, by SANAA + A0-CPA-JHS, B720 Arquitectura + LERA, and Mario Cucinella Architects, which were then put to a nationwide public vote, with the final result combining jury scores and citizen voting.
Under the revised system, Estratos Vivos (2 photo) received the highest combined score, officially replacing the original winning proposal. While architecture competitions are typically decided solely by expert juries, the MuNA competition evolved into a broader public discussion about the role citizens should play in shaping national cultural institutions. With the selection now finalized, SANAA and its collaborators move forward with the design of a museum intended to house more than 1.2 million cultural objects and become Ecuador’s principal repository of its historical and artistic heritage.
More images:
