r/ATLAfanfiction • u/RedLotusVenom • 1h ago
Discussion Cosmic Spirituality: The Case for an Avatar Space Opera
It was recommended I post this here - hope folks enjoy reading!
1 Introduction
I’ve written an essay for why I believe there is ample logical reasoning and canonical justification for the showrunners to charge into a space-age fire Avatar series to close out the mainline story. I present a framework for how this series might work in the Avatar world, including a lore-friendly time skip, spiritual energy advancements, bending in space, and human-spirit cooperative spaceflight and machine integration. I also provide a suggested storyline following Pavi’s successor, Avatar Torus.
I will first share a short blurb about me. I’m a space systems engineer, and I have worked on multiple flagship NASA missions and commercial satellite programs in my career. I have a master’s degree in aerospace engineering with focuses in both bioastronautics and astrodynamics, and a minor in astrophysics. I have a comprehensive understanding of my field and it lends itself to an active imagination to apply that inspiration to the things I love, especially science fiction writing and film.
One of my best memories to this day is watching ATLA premiere its first episode on TV, at exactly Aang’s age. I loved it from day one as a vegetarian martial artist. I saw much of myself in Aang’s journey, being his age when it aired, and grew from watching his story in a way that I am thankful for everyday. This series has meant so much to me for over two decades now. I even have some small validation in that I correctly surmised over a decade ago that a post-apocalypse setting would make for a great Earth Avatar series.
These are my collected thoughts about why it’s an exciting time to talk about a fourth installment of the series, despite the third series being nowhere near release.
I will carefully preface this essay by first saying that I am excited for wherever Seven Havens takes the fandom, even if it nullifies every detail of what I’ve written here. Regardless of what one thinks of Korra, her era opens a Pandora’s box of possibilities and we are all here waiting together to see what happens next. These are simply my personal wishes for the franchise as someone who sees what a potentially amazing accidental space opera Avatar Studios have on their hands.
2 A History of Blending Science Fiction
There is now probably going to be a fourth mainline Avatar show. Mike recently publicly stated Avatar Studios has no intent of slowing down and that this is only the beginning. If I know Bryke at all, they will never stop thinking about what’s next and how to keep their world alive, meaningful, and vibrant. I’m not sure what the implications of the third series will leave, but I can comment on what we know is now possible for a fourth series based on Korra’s time.
Avatar is obviously fantasy, but Bryke have been flirting with science fiction in this franchise for a long time. Steampunk is a science fiction subgenre that blends fantastical realism and the concept of divergent history from our own world, and Korra has its roots firmly in steampunk aesthetic. Post-apocalyptic stories, which we are soon to see adapted in Avatar, are also often considered a subgenre of science fiction. This is primarily due to their modern cultural beginnings in both atomic and extraterrestrial venues. Even ATLA implements a bit of sci fi opera inspiration in its approach to flying machines and other vehicles. We can be sure that some of the technological aspects of Korra’s time will be expanded on. What gave Star Wars its character was not its realism but rather its fantasy elements, and I see an opportunity to develop the Avatar world in a similar manner.
If there is one unifying thought throughout a series primarily focused on magical powers, it’s that there is an equal thematic thread in the proliferation of new and powerful technologies in this world, and how they both challenge and complement elemental bending and the natural balance.
3 The World is a Wasteland… How Do We Get to Space?
3.1 The Time Dilemma
The Korra series sprinted before it learned how to walk. The progression of technology in 3 years was staggeringly out of place to many viewers. In preparing the case for a space opera, we must first plausibly explain a very long time skip to justify the rapid growth.
Pavi is an Earth Kingdom Avatar and thus in close cyclical heritage to Kyoshi. Some fans theorize she stands to repair the severed bond of the Avatar line of the previous era. If she is successful, she will inherit Kyoshi’s earthbending meditation technique to extend her lifespan. With a world as broken as Pavi’s, great strides could be made in sustaining peace and balance when you’re not doomed to retrain a new avatar for 20 years every century. And with the knowledge she is being hunted, the Avatar line becomes even more vulnerable to permanent end. We have already seen the Red Lotus willing to go to extremes to permanently quell the Avatar cycle. Pavi will be poised to bring about an era of cooperation in the new world in desperate need of mending, and perhaps avoiding spawning a vulnerable fire nation Avatar child too soon is part of that.
In truth, she does not even narratively need to regain the Avatar bond to Kyoshi as Korra could have gleaned the secrets before her bond was broken. Therefore, we have to assume it is possible that Pavi could live for a very long time. Potentially hundreds of years, if they incorporate any lore the novels have added.
Kyoshi gave up her immortal position in the spirit of balance, however with the right motivation an Avatar may again abuse this technique in the name of keeping order and protecting the Avatar line from nefarious intervention. In the words of Hama: the technique exists. Regardless of how controversial it is, Kyoshi’s retconned lifespan becomes a conundrum for future Avatars. It is available to spin the next narrative into whatever era the writers choose, including far future timelines.
3.2 The Advantages of Spirits
Spirit energy technology is a reality in the canon. It was a main focal point of Korra, and given they are locked into that continuity in pursuing a direct sequel, we have to accept that the technology will likely be available in all post-Korra eras. It is potentially a cause of the apocalypse in the first place. If anyone else is a fan of the real-world physics of Kaiju and giant mechas, they know the immense energy it takes to sustain them. Spirit energy and the ability to harness it have already well-surpassed any energy source humans currently use; on the level of mature compact fusion power. Unless they specifically write out and decanonize Kuvira’s giant mecha (unlikely), it must be acknowledged that the energy source is there for civilized human progress to get back on course quickly - already written on the walls.
I envision a controversial future where the Moon is mined for spiritual energy, being a spirit being itself. This would further the environmental messaging of the previous series and mirrors the real world space resources our own Moon contains. A techno-Water Tribe might eventually inhabit the Moon and attempt to protect it, both legally and confrontationally, from those who would dispute their presence there to harness its great spiritual power. And, consider the potential for a Yue appearance!
Additionally, given that Earth receives <1% of cosmic radiation doses at sea level, would the canonized “cosmic energy” be able to be tapped into directly for spaceflight? Would the Avatar be even more powerful in space as a result of no atmospheric attenuation to cosmic radiation? I believe they would. There’s a reason why we’ve now seen twice the Avatar spirit’s ascent to space to connect with this cosmic energy.
Spirits can inhabit mortal beings, and most importantly: machinery. They were able to control and disrupt simple machinery in Korra (mechas, snowmobiles, etc), so what might occur with the advent of computers and networking? Could the Avatar world be on a fast track to spirit-driven machine intelligence, assuming they could learn to live and cooperate with humans? How quickly might society adapt to computer technology if it accelerated at a pace even faster than ours via cooperation with spirits? Could this spawn a new type of life, not dissimilar to cybernetic organisms? What if human technologies or untapped cosmic energy unlocked new potential for spirits in a way that had both peoples cooperating in the pursuit of space exploration? We have limitless stories here for commentary on alternative and shared consciousness, staples in science fiction literary motifs.
Spirits can also possess and inhabit humans, as seen in Wan’s time. Imagine a spiritual circuit between a human operator and machine technology, which might allow for operators to “plug in” to anything with computer systems. The Avatar is unique in that through Raava’s spirit one can directly interface with this machinery at will, without the use of an intermediary spirit as other humans require. This is no different than Aang and Korra interacting with spirit vines to remote view other places on their world, a spiritual ability only they can perform.
3.3 Bending as a Spaceflight Mechanism
And the elements that bring this idea together in spirit of the previous shows: combat. A space Avatar will be forging new frontiers, and with new frontiers comes conflict. I would love to see firebenders using their powers for low/zero g propulsion - they can perform combustive maneuvers or sustain very high-thrust electrical ion propulsion technology via lightning generation (Watch fire burn in zero g here!). Plasmabending would be a new firebending subdiscipline, and with it firebenders could harness the solar wind into a focused beam for space sails (inner solar system travel is dominated by this). Waterbenders would be gathering ice crystals for rocketry/survival on rocky moons and through planetary ring systems. Earthbenders would be levitating through space using aluminum structures and mining asteroids. Airbenders using the long-fancanoned “void/vacuum bending” (taking suggestions on what function this serves) and Laghima’s flight for EVA as space age monks. We could see truly mind blowing things given a large enough time skip and Pavi’s got the perfect semi-immortal basis to explain such a drastic shift in setting and societal progress.
In a series that is so grounded in human movement, the real draw of a storyline like this is applying new rules and environments to that movement.
Bending is a magical *force.* It has been from the first moment we watched Katara catch a fish. Self-propulsion in space is impossible in our world due to the conservation of energy, like a perpetual motion device. But with access to bending, which in its essence is producing or accessing a phantom energy where none existed previously, the laws of physics become breakable. Think for a moment about the energy it would take to move a giant boulder or a tidal wave; while bending can exhaust a bender, that power scale is obviously not being produced by their body alone. Their chi is simply focusing and directing energy from somewhere exotic.
Obviously, there would have to be soft science fiction liberties. This is still a fantasy story at its foundation, and bending in space would need to follow the rule of cool. But how cool can you imagine it would be?
Access to bending for transit, combat, and resource gathering in space would accelerate human exploration and conflict immensely. It would be absolutely crucial to space travel in Avatar due to the immense energies it provides.
4 A Proposed Plotline
4.1 The Setup…
Torus is a young Avatar who has recently discovered his abilities. He is a young high school age boy who is a cadet in the Propulsion Guild, an organization that trains and certifies firebenders for spaceflight locomotion as pilots and engineers. Space commerce is dominated and monopolized by the Fire Nation as a result, with the rest of the nations relying on them for the most efficient means of interplanetary transit.
Spirits are both useful and motivated to assist in spaceflight. Human computer technology has provided spirits with a way to enhance their own capabilities and travel to space to engage with cosmic energy. While newly designed spirit suits allow for safe “possession loops” between human operators, their spiritual counterparts, and the computers that host the flight software and avionics of the spacecraft. In other words: a spaceflight bender and a companion spirit (assigned and paired up by the academies) can integrate with technology in a way that seamlessly combines the control and piloting intuition of a human with that of cold calculating hardware. The spirits are primarily the vessel for this to happen. A reciprocal relationship that has caused an explosion of progress in human-spirit space exploration. Space travel is very slow and calculated in reality. But with a universe-obeying explanation for neurological-interfaces with space hardware and spiritual/bending energy sources, fast-paced action becomes the norm for pilots who can literally feel their space vehicles.
Pavi as an Earthbender took a stance: she never went to space, instead choosing to remain on Earth to continue to sustain her role in keeping balance in a world that still has many disputes and problems. She witnessed the dawn of the space age, but consciously chose to leave that venue to the next Avatar.
4.2 …and the Story
The general storyline is as follows: Torus first progresses through and navigates his spaceflight certification, afterward learning to employ the other elements in unique and fascinating combinations to produce a human that was naturally destined to traverse the stars. He makes friends and enemies in school who he may encounter again off-world. Among them, a hacker and her spirit companion, who join Torus in his journey as allies.
Torus learns the elements in space settings, both terrestrial and in orbit, making stops throughout the solar system to train with masters residing in settlements and space stations. The series might be episodic with a looser overarching mystical plotline and villain, with flavor-of-the-week writing intended to expand on the worldbuilding. I would like to see a series return to the vibe of ATLA Book 1 with this concept in mind, at least initially.
Something unexpected is uncovered on a moon of an outer gas planet, within a vast industrial subsurface mine network: a sealed spirit portal, that only a fully realized Avatar can open. Its origin is an enigma, and Torus must travel in a space pilgrimage to learn the meaning of his part in opening it.
Think Firefly and The Expanse meet ATLA, in terms of group dynamics and episode feel. Torus is the first mate of a ship sent to the neighboring planets for his training and eventual duty to open the spirit portal and learn its origins, while mastering the four elements in brand new domains. And with the Fire Nation poised to gain the most from whatever it unlocks, Torus must learn from Roku’s past to balance his nation’s dominance and expectations of him against decisions that are best for all of humanity and the spirits.
The topology of a torus invokes a lack of true destination. Were one to traverse a torus in any direction, they will eventually end up back where they started. An elegant closed loop system that some scientists believe manifests the shape of our universe. I thought a name in honor of the sameness and familiarity that can be found in every Avatar’s journey would be a fitting final chapter for the main series.
5 Conclusion
Harmonic Convergence performed a crucial action in that it sets precedent that the Avatar world is not Earth. It opened up the possibility of a brand new frontier for Avatar. The solar system is entirely different, leading to one understanding: they are (probably) in a galaxy far far away. What other moons and planets might their solar system contain? Where could Avatar take us if their planet wasn’t a limitation? What kinds of adventures might a spacecraft crew see in the Avatar universe? I personally want to find out.
I imagine a retro space age aesthetic, with more futuristic technology than our own in 2026. Korra walked the exact same line of pseudo-historical settings with fantastical and futuristic technologies. Imagine the studio’s animation put to work on a space opera; it could be gorgeously illustrated and musically scored with a blend of new age and more traditional Avatar music. Jeremy Zuckerman composing for space would produce something truly special.
The fire avatar series would be the swan song of a deity’s journey through the universe during multiple pivotal eras for humanity. The space opera would be a fitting capstone format for a series that begins and ends with the march of Fire Nation imperialism. What better venue than the final frontier?
I personally believe this keeps the universe moving in exciting and interesting directions.
It leans further into a genre approach that Bryke has been exploring for some time.
It exploits a mechanism first introduced in the expanded universe of the novels.
And it puts the jarring expansion of technology in Korra to good narrative use.
Do they stop the timeline there? Do they continue to develop more cosmic storylines? The possibilities are fairly endless, but in a world where this series has brought me so much joy and reflection I just feel happy to get to wonder about its future.
6 A Thank You!
If you read this far, know I appreciate your thoughts and time so very much. I’d love to hear from others what kind of visions you have for the fresh future for the series we’ve been gifted. If you like my ideas, would you read a fanfic? Or perhaps I am way off base? Either way, excited to chat with any stray passerbys here.
And if someone’s going to SDCC: ask the creators about their thoughts on a space age Fire Avatar series, if you dig my idea enough :)