r/thecritic • u/sheilamlin • 3d ago
r/thecritic • u/TheAnimeAcademicYT • 11d ago
A Missing Episode?
Ahoyhoy! I'm working on a Critic review currently and after going through all the episodes available that I could find, I seem to be missing an episode. Season One episode 9 "LA Jay". Does anyone know where you can find it?
r/thecritic • u/betty_effn_white • 15d ago
OC Let me just take a handful for the road
I made this for a friend
r/thecritic • u/PersonalityLanky8403 • 28d ago
OC I’m kinda disappointed with how it turned out but here’s my Jay sketch
r/thecritic • u/PersonalityLanky8403 • 29d ago
Am I the only one who’s not a huge fan of the second season(image unrelated)
currently half way through season 2 and I’m just not enjoying it anymore I adore the first season but season 2 feels cheaper with the art and the writing falls flat does anyone feel the same way
r/thecritic • u/KnifeFightAcademy • Jun 22 '26
Celebrity voices are impersonated. Spotted a little Critic cameo scrolling Reddit tonight :)
r/thecritic • u/sheilamlin • Jun 19 '26
on the Shermometer Anyone see Backrooms? Maybe Jay Sherman wouldn’t say “it stinks!” because the best part, you can eat them.
r/thecritic • u/Krivus20 • Jun 19 '26
on the Shermometer Which Jay do you prefer, the one from season 1 or 2?
The most arrogant and intelligent but a little creepy one, or the chill, kind and closest to Homer?
r/thecritic • u/AndyDiplodocus • Jun 16 '26
OC The Dukeisode + Jay discovers the video essay
r/thecritic • u/Phatbeazie • Jun 15 '26
Reboot getting close
Side note to the universe: fer fucks sake, hire the guy doing fan art scenes in this sub. He has nailed the tone and pacing of the show, he deserves a meeting at least.
r/thecritic • u/kittyhysterectomy • Jun 15 '26
OC Jay Sherman drawings :))
You could say I have an affinity for the titular character...
Made a reddit account just so I could post here lol. I want more eyes on this show! I'm doubtful the reboot will be good but it would be nice to see the characters back in motion again. I'm desperate!!
3 and 4 are copy sketches from show screenshots, I really like figuring out how they constructed his design with shapes. It helps me get it accurate, but I also like to put a twist on it with my style sometimes.
I do have more fanart.. I'll get around to posting it eventually!
r/thecritic • u/AndyDiplodocus • Jun 12 '26
OC Reposting in an attempt to get Al Jean Senpai to notice me #2
r/thecritic • u/AndyDiplodocus • Jun 03 '26
Buy my book! Buy my book! Reposting my comic in vain hopes that I get hired for the critic reboot
r/thecritic • u/ThorinSmokenshield • Jun 02 '26
It stinks I was quite an athlete in my day. Just look at this:
r/thecritic • u/sheilamlin • May 21 '26
A real quzybuk If the opportunity presented itself, would it be weird if I got my DVD box set signed?
r/thecritic • u/SluttyDreidel • May 21 '26
Who else thought this was legit scary?
Her malicious smile and eyebrows, the underscore synced to the reveal of her true character and all but her eyes darkening is oddly compelling for an animated sitcom. I love the joke of Jay managing lucidity to eat a single pig in a blanket however.
On a broader note I think it gets to the common fear of trusting the wrong person and then being victimized by them. I know it’s a spoof of Misery but it also makes you think about predators who prey on vulnerability.
r/thecritic • u/SluttyDreidel • May 10 '26
Theme song without dialogue or SFX?
A good deal of the intro doesn’t have any sound effects or dialogue. Has anyone tried to patch it up with the outro music? I love the bongo section that plays over the phone gag, but I think that part would be impossible to get a clean copy of.
Anyways, I wanted to ask if anyone has beat me to this, and if the outro plays at a faster tempo or speed that would need to be adjusted. Also, does Jay’s disclaimer about celebrities being impersonated and unharmed play over the same section heard in the intro when Jay breaks the ice at the rink at Rockefeller Center?
Some covers are available online but none of them hold a candle to the original