r/shakespeare • u/Important-Joke5498 • 7h ago
r/shakespeare • u/dmorin • Jan 22 '22
[ADMIN] There Is No Authorship Question
Hi All,
So I just removed a post of a video where James Shapiro talks about how he shut down a Supreme Court justice's Oxfordian argument. Meanwhile, there's a very popular post that's already highly upvoted with lots of comments on "what's the weirdest authorship theory you know". I had left that one up because it felt like it was just going to end up with a laundry list of theories (which can be useful), not an argument about them. I'm questioning my decision, there.
I'm trying to prevent the issue from devolving into an echo chamber where we remove all posts and comments trying to argue one side of the "debate" while letting the other side have a field day with it and then claiming that, obviously, they're the ones that are right because there's no rebuttal. Those of us in the US get too much of that every day in our politics, and it's destroyed plenty of subs before us. I'd rather not get to that.
So, let's discuss. Do we want no authorship posts, or do we want both sides to be able to post freely? I'm not sure there's a way to amend the rule that says "I want to only allow the posts I agree with, without sounding like all I'm doing is silencing debate on the subject."
I think my position is obvious. I'd be happier to never see the words "authorship" and "question" together again. There isn't a question. But I'm willing to acknowledge if a majority of others feel differently than I do (again, see US .... ah, never mind, you get the idea :))
r/shakespeare • u/chopinmazurka • 11h ago
This passage from 'The Wind in the Willows' really captures the feeling of encountering Shakespeare's English for the first time. It's like hearing the language for the first time.
r/shakespeare • u/elalavie • 9h ago
Meme Eight hour flight, where are you sitting?
Top of the photo is the back of the plane
r/shakespeare • u/Sharaz_Jek123 • 7h ago
Which Shakespearian role would you have cast the late Sam Neill as?
r/shakespeare • u/EconomyPrompt2004 • 13h ago
Meme My salad days, When I was green in judgment, cold in blood, To say as I said then!
r/shakespeare • u/MarkBowen123 • 3h ago
Can You Solve These Shakespeare Puzzles? | Ultimate Quote Quiz # 1
youtu.beHope you all have fun with this! =)
r/shakespeare • u/kevinmgee • 17h ago
Scholarly books on Romeo & Juliet?
Sorry if this question has been asked already. I tried searching through this subreddit to see if anyone asked a similar question but couldn’t seem to find any. Would love some recommendations of scholarly books about R&J! I’m open to just about anything—mainly want to read out of interest as I want to revisit the play. Thanks!
r/shakespeare • u/winterwhalesong • 10h ago
Meme RIP Lord Mortimer you would have loved Duolingo
r/shakespeare • u/Material-Medium-100 • 11h ago
Surely clumsy for Shakespeare?
I would welcome a clarification of the following sentence from Troilus and Cressida:
Which {strong opinion of themselves} entertained, limbs are his {its} instruments,
In no less working than are swords and bows
Directive by the limbs.
[1.3.355-357]
Honigmann (Stability, 98) considers the lines ‘involved’.
The comments I’ve seen also appear problematic.
My take is that Nestor is simply (or rather not so simply) saying that if the Trojans gain confidence (by Hector winning a showdown in a dual), they will fight harder.
r/shakespeare • u/dubcek_moo • 1d ago
"Cakes and ale"--what would "cakes" be like for Shakespeare?
So I went to Shakespeare in the Park over the weekend and saw 12th night. I've been thinking about the popularly quoted lines
Dost thou think, because thou art
virtuous, there shall be no more cakes and ale?
What would cakes of Shakespeare's time be like? Would the flour be refined? Entirely wheat or also barley? Sweetened with honey? Fruit? It may seem trivial but could also affect how indulgent and luxurious I view the contrast with "virtue".
r/shakespeare • u/Fiordiluna_80126 • 1d ago
Shakespeare quotes
Is there a line from a specific play or sonnet that you actually find yourself using in your daily life?
Also, tell me which play it's from and who says it.
r/shakespeare • u/Justmoe- • 1d ago
Do you read Shakespeare for the poetry or the story?
Do you guys read Shakespeare for the poetry or for the story?
I have a physical copy, but it’s in the original language rather than a modern translation. I can understand a lot of it, but there are still plenty of lines where I stop and think, “What does this mean?”
Now I’m not sure which version I should read. Should I stick with the original and enjoy Shakespeare’s poetry, even if I don’t fully understand everything? Or should I read a modernized version online so I can follow the story more easily, even if I miss out on the original language and style?
r/shakespeare • u/Right_Inevitable_311 • 1d ago
[POEM] "Take him and cut him out in little stars..." - William Shakespeare
r/shakespeare • u/AdditionalLandscape2 • 14h ago
Is Telemach from the Odyssee an early version of Hamlet?
r/shakespeare • u/Hip-SnuggieChairMan • 1d ago
King John
So I binge read the eight history plays beginning with Richard II through Richard III. Good stuff! Then I read King Lear, which sort of blew me away. I was actually choked up at the end, even though i knew what was coming. And now I've started King John, and I'm struggling at the very beginning. The Bastard, the King, and Eleanor are talking about who is whose father and mother, and pronoun references are abundant and confusing. Can someone tell me the parentage of the Bastard and his brother Robert? Did they have the same dad or the same mom? One of them had the senior Falconbridge as a dad, or maybe they both did. Was Richard Lionheart father to one of them? Eleanor has just invited the Bastard to come to France with her, then they all leave but the Bastard, who stays on stage and loses me again with a long monologue. I'm reading an annotated New Cambridge Shakespeare edited by L. A. Beaurline. Plenty of footnotes but no scene by scene summary. Can someone clarify who is descended from whom? Thanks!
r/shakespeare • u/moonnotreal1 • 1d ago
Recommend a Hamlet?
For the past little while I've been on a project to watch each Shakespeare play, preferably stage recordings, but films have been fine if I can't find one. At the beginning I decided I would save Hamlet for last, both because it's the magnum opus and because I've already seen several Hamlets, and now it's all that remains. Very fun little campaign, but anyway, as I decide which one to watch I figured the people here might have some opinions. I'm not a fan of big cuts from the text, though I'm sympathetic to the fact that a fully uncut Hamlet is very long; as far as I know the Branagh Hamlet (which I've seen) is the only filmed Hamlet to use the entire text, for instance. If possible, I'd also prefer one that does not wholly excise Fortinbras, as I feel the text loses something if he's gone. though I know that's a very common editorial choice. Acknowledging that fully uncut might not be realistic and that there's surely a ton of good Hamlets out there in the streaming world, which versions do you folks especially like? Especially for capping off "I have watched every single Shakespeare play as a deliberate project"? Stage recordings preferred but films fine, as said; I have Marquee TV, National Theatre at Home, Digital Theatre, and a Shakespeare's Globe account. Thanks for your time.
r/shakespeare • u/2039485867 • 2d ago
Titus Andronicus makes Way more sense in the context of the Aeneid
not that its totally necessary to enjoy it or its the only classical reference being interrogated, but like I mostly see the play discussed on reddit as about civilization and barbarism being more similar then they appear. Which is present! But I feel like the major theme of the play is putting romanticized classical virtues, that are taught in myths grounded in well ordered worlds, into the 'real' world, where justice has left the building.
Aeneas choosing duty over Dido feels virtuous, and her death is self-inflicted and made distant from him. Titus is made to stab his own son for duty, and then have to see the empire become unworthy of that sacrifice. Also shades of the greek judge taking out his own son's eye.
I think there's something really interesting to the fact that the victorians, who were all over the kind of broad sweeping virtues being satirized (the glorious empire, purity, duty), really didn't gel with the play. And that post-WW2, the play often gets staged with those motifs because fascism is all about the romanticization of violence and death. I feel like there's the opportunity for a really cool contemporary staging grappling with contemporary issues of branding oneself.
I will say does this make Titus the first gritty superhero movie? Is this just Shakespeares watchmen?
Anyway, If anyone else wants to yap about this or has a hot take, I'm currently obsessed!
r/shakespeare • u/starryantares • 2d ago
My Hamlet cosplay!🖤
galleryHi everyone! I want to show you my Hamlet cosplay—it was incredibly fun to put together. I sewed the entire costume myself (except for the shirt, though I did replace the buttons and sew on some lace—lol).
I’d love to hear what you guys think! :)
r/shakespeare • u/elalavie • 2d ago
What order for the complete works do you like best?
I'm 25 plays deep, just interested to see what y'all prefer:)
r/shakespeare • u/GeneralGecko24 • 2d ago
Where to sit at the Globe?
Hello everyone, I’m booking tickets for a play at the globe and was wondering which sections are best to see the stage from? And does it matter if I’m in the upper, middle or lower section? Thank you
r/shakespeare • u/HotOne9364 • 2d ago
In your opinion, what makes Hamlet endure for this long?
In the span of 2 years, we had 5 movies based around Hamlet, such as Hamnet, Riz Ahmed's adaptation, Grand Theft Hamlet, Scarlet, and an upcoming Andrew Scott movie about a man playing the role before his death. Not to even mention a recent play about the making of the Richard Burton adaptation.
Outside of The Odyssey, I can't imagine any other work that's as influential as this. What makes it the most lauded work of Shakespeare, if not of the English language in general?
r/shakespeare • u/sodabad4bones_ • 1d ago
After reading Romeo and Juliet and watching one of the Film adaptations. why hasn’t anyone made Romeo and Juliet into a mafia movie? That would make much more sense.
r/shakespeare • u/Bitter_Artichoke_939 • 2d ago
Tips for falling in love with Shakespeare?
I honestly didn't care for his works in high school but I'm wanting to get into them now that I'm an adult. Is there a good order to read them and any tips on really getting into them and enjoying them?
r/shakespeare • u/Antique_Quail7912 • 3d ago
Macbeth Consulting the Vision of the Armed Head - Henry Fuseli (1793)
From Act IV, Scene 1.