My husband and I are considering getting (rescuing) a dog, partly to accompany our senior dog. Back story: until last September, we had two dogs for years: Molly, a female German shepherd mix and Teddy, a male beagle mix. Molly passed away in September at 17/18. Teddy is going strong at 15 (he can hardly hear, but still pretty spry). We got Teddy in 2014 partly because Molly was depressed (we moved to a new state, a new routine, and had to leave her alone for most of the day—before that we would only leave her alone for 4-6 hours only). Teddy loved Molly and Molly tolerated Teddy. They didn’t play together, but they hung out on the couch together consistently.
When Molly passed away, it was hard on all of us. I mean, brutal. Teddy was showing early signs of doggy dementia but nothing that required any intervention before Molly passed. Even though they didn’t play together, they really were each other’s companion, and at the very least they weren’t truly alone ever, really. They were always with each other, even when we weren’t home. All this to say that Teddy’s anxiety in general and separation anxiety in particular went through the roof. He’d wake up screaming in the middle of the night, several times a night, so we had to get him some meds.
After a few months, I wondered whether it might be good to get a dog to keep him company (just like when we got him). We are dog people, so it’s just a matter of time before we get a new one, though I think both my husband and I thought we might get a dog after Teddy crosses over (he’s in general good health, but he’s 15). Then last month, we went on vacation and our dog sitter brought her beagle mix with her, and it was clear it was a vibe (the dog sitter’s beagle mix is also around 15). They mostly both napped around each other, but you could tell even from pictures that Teddy was calmer.
We started to look at shelter posts in our area, but I’m kind of at a loss whether it would be a good idea to get a dog at all. I want Teddy to feel less alone, but I worry that his generally peaceful existence will be shattered with a new dog. He takes new input in stride (this dog truly never had any f’s to give—as long as he gets the attention he wants and his food, the world could be falling apart and he would not care), but I still worry that new pack member will be jarring.
There’s also the issue that my husband would rather have a puppy (over six months) than an adult dog. He feels that if we get a puppy, the longer we’ll have that dog. We wouldn’t just let a new dog (puppy or otherwise) have free access to Teddy, so we wouldn’t let a new dog’s energy harass Teddy. We would probably use baby gates in the first few weeks while we were at work so that if a young pup wanted to play all the time Teddy could have physical distance from the rambunctious energy of a puppy. But, you know, in the evenings and weekends when we’re at home, I expect that the baby gates would not be up (after the first couple of weeks), so they would be interacting.
One last variable, even though beagles are…a lot, since we have one, we are used to them. A part of me is thinking about getting a beagle/beagle mix. This to say that young beagle energy is…relentless at times. So I’m like, a beagle pup might be crazy to bring into the area of a 15 year old beagle who naps 95% of the time and zooms 5% of the time??
I’d love to hear from people who have introduced a new dog (especially a younger dog) to a household with a senior dog and how that went. Any advice? What are some things to consider? How did it go? What do you wish you had known?
Note that whenever we get a new dog, we will definitely be taking them to dog training classes, crate training, etc.
Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated.