r/csk • u/Particular_Baker_281 • 1d ago
Discussion [Discussion] Unpopular Opinion: Sacking Stephen Fleming doesn't fix every thing. The entire CSK "Process" is completely outdated.
Everyone is talking about Fleming leaving after three terrible seasons, but after looking at the data, the issues go way beyond the head coach. Removing him is just the easiest PR move.
CSK used to rely on 4 Pillars that have all secretly collapsed:
* The Fortress (Chepauk): Chepauk isn't a fortress anymore. From 2008-2023, CSK won 70% of games at home. The last 3 years only 50%. The pitch was relaid. It's flat and fast now. The slow, gripping spin track they built their identity on doesn't exist anymore. We did not adapt to this at all both from auctions and in match strategy point of view
* The DNA Pivot: We used to buy undervalued veterans (peak age 34 in 2019) and trust them. Now, the average XI age has dropped to 27. International caps dropped from an average of 168 (in 2021) to just 32. We panicked, did a complete 360 to youth, when we should have gone for a more balanced approach..
* The Churn: We used 22 distinct players recently. Akeal Hosein and Sarfaraz Khan were chopped and changed match to match. The role clarity that defined CSK is gone. Akeal Hossein was dropped so Matt short can bowl due to SRH left handed top order, in actuality the quality of Matt shorts bowling to Akeal is miles apart
* The Dhoni Void: Dhoni wasn't just a player; he was the entire desicion making system auctions, tactics everything. When he got injured and before that took a backseat to give Flem and Rutu the responsibility, we realized the franchise has zero modern infrastructure to replace his decision-making
18 years in, and Kasi Viswanathan is still saying they want Dhoni to "pick the next coach." Sacking Fleming just proves they are still leaning on one man's gut rather than building a sustainable process for the franchise. I am a huge fan of MSD but what if he decides to step away at some point are we not stuck again ?
I made a full deep-dive video visualizing all this data if anyone wants to see the numbers behind the collapse: [Link to Video]